Skip to content
Wild10

Become a contributor

Join

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Top 10 Wind River Trout Lakes head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Island Lake

#8 on this list

Island Lake

Bridger Wilderness, Wyoming

Island Lake is the undisputed crossroads of the central Bridger Wilderness, situated at 10,380 feet. Characterized by its granite islets and deeply indented shoreline, the lake sits right at the edge of the subalpine and alpine zones, offering both cutthroat trout and lingering populations of brookies and goldens. Located 12 miles from Elkhart Park outside Pinedale, Island Lake serves as the staging ground for pushes into Titcomb and Indian Basins. While it sees substantial wilderness camping traffic, the sheer size of the lake and its numerous bays mean an angler willing to hike off the trail can easily find quiet water. The optimal window spans from late July through the end of August. The fishing is varied. Shallow weed beds in the warmer western coves support healthy invertebrate life, while the drop-offs around the central islands hold larger, predatory cruisers. Stripping woolly buggers or leeches on an intermediate line during overcast afternoons often provokes the lake's better fish. **Highlights** * Elevation: 10,380 feet * Target species: Cutthroat trout, golden trout, brook trout * Mileage: 12 miles one-way from Elkhart Park * Extensive shoreline with multiple bays, shelves, and granite points * Reliable base camp infrastructure with good water sources **Watch-outs** * High human density and heavily impacted designated campsites * Strict wilderness food-storage regulations enforced by USFS rangers * Extended trek through the burn zone near the trailhead on hot days

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Golden Lake

#9 on this list

Golden Lake

Bridger Wilderness, Wyoming

Golden Lake lies at 10,200 feet deep in the northern midsection of the range, well away from the popular tourist circuits. True to its name, the water supports wild golden trout that maintain their numbers through natural spawning in the rocky inlet creeks draining the surrounding high plateau. Reaching Golden Lake is an expedition. From the Boulder Creek or Scab Creek trailheads, anglers face a minimum of 20 miles across undulating, granite-studded terrain with significant total elevation change. Pinedale is the last supply town. Because of the long approach, Golden Lake is best tackled as part of a five- to seven-day unsupported backcountry traverse. The trout here are not monsters—most run 8 to 12 inches—but their coloration is vivid, with fiery orange bellies and gold-dusted flanks. The clear water requires extreme stealth; kneeling on the rock slabs and casting from behind boulders is standard practice. **Highlights** * Elevation: 10,200 feet * Target species: Wild golden trout * Exceptional isolation with virtually zero day-hiker traffic * Pristine wilderness setting surrounded by unnamed tarns * Authentic backcountry test of navigation and self-reliance **Watch-outs** * Significant distance from trailheads (20+ miles one-way) * Navigation requires map-and-compass skills over faint trails * Zero cell coverage and slow evacuation times in emergencies

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Island Lake versus Golden Lake specifications
SpecIsland LakeGolden Lake
Surface Elevation10,380 feet—
TrailheadElkhart Park—
Approach Distance12 miles one-way—
Target SpeciesCutthroat trout, brook troutWild Golden Trout
Managing AgencyBridger-Teton National Forest—
Prime WindowLate July through August—
Elevation—10,200 feet
Distance—20+ miles one-way from trailhead
Access Points—Scab Creek or Boulder Creek Trailheads
Jurisdiction—Bridger Wilderness, Bridger-Teton National Forest
Gateway Town—Pinedale, Wyoming

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Island Lake

  • Diverse underwater structure with points, weed beds, and island drop-offs
  • Superb base camp for quick morning pushes into Titcomb and Indian Basins
  • Reliable cutthroat and brook trout action on both dries and streamers
  • Well-engineered approach trail with abundant water access en route
  • High campsite density and significant human presence around the trail
  • Strict two-hundred-foot lakeshore setback limits good tent sites
  • Punishing mosquito populations through early and mid-July

Golden Lake

  • Naturally reproducing wild golden trout with exceptional coloration
  • Profound solitude with virtually no day-hiking or weekend foot traffic
  • Untrammeled wilderness scenery ringed by rugged granite peaks and tarns
  • Superb water clarity that rewards stealthy technical sight-fishing
  • Grueling 20-plus mile approach each way filters out short itineraries
  • Trout rarely exceed 12 inches due to short high-altitude growing seasons
  • Extremely remote location with slow emergency evacuation response times

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.