Skip to content
Wild10

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Best Backpacking Tents head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Back to the full Top 10
Half Dome SL 2+

#9 on this list

Half Dome SL 2+

REI Co-op

The REI Co-op Half Dome SL 2+ is the quintessential starter tent for aspiring thru-hikers and an enduring favorite for backpackers on a budget. Don't let the 'budget' label fool you; this is a seriously capable tent. The 'SL' (Superlight) means it's lighter than older Half Dome models, and the '2+' indicates it offers a little extra elbow room than a standard two-person tent, making it genuinely comfortable for two people and their gear, or a palatial solo shelter. This is a fully freestanding, double-wall tent, which means setup is a breeze on any terrain, and it handles condensation effectively. The robust aluminum pole architecture provides excellent stability in wind and rain, instilling confidence when the weather turns. We've taken previous iterations of the Half Dome into some truly nasty environments, and it has consistently performed, keeping us dry and shielded. While it's not an ultralight gram-saver compared to others on this list, its durability and livability for the price are unmatched. Dual doors and two large vestibules ensure everyone has their own space. It's an ideal choice for backpackers who prioritize space, durability, and a lower cost, and don't mind carrying a few extra ounces for that peace of mind. A true workhorse. **Highlights** * Excellent value and durability for the price * Fully freestanding design for easy pitching on any terrain * Generous interior space for two, plus extra room ('2+') * Dual doors and large vestibules * Robust construction handles varied weather conditions well **Watch-outs** * Heavier than truly ultralight tents * Pack size is larger than many ultralight models * Ventilation can be less effective in extremely humid, still conditions * Not the most aesthetically pleasing design for some

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
FreeLite 2

#10 on this list

FreeLite 2

MSR

The MSR FreeLite 2 is a solid option for backpackers who want the reliability and quality of MSR in a lighter, semi-freestanding package. It sits somewhere between the robust Hubba Hubba and the featherlight ultralight models, aiming for a good balance of weight and livability. This double-wall tent retains much of MSR's bombproof design philosophy but uses lighter fabrics and a more minimalist pole structure. The semi-freestanding pitch is fairly intuitive, though the foot end requires staking for optimal interior volume. It’s ideal for backpackers who are looking to lighten their load from traditional setups but aren’t quite ready for a fully non-freestanding trekking pole tent. The interior space is adequate for two average-sized people, and the dual doors and decent-sized vestibules are appreciated amenities. We've found its weather protection to be dependable in moderate conditions, and the ventilation does a good job of minimizing condensation. While the fabrics are thin, MSR's construction quality is high, providing peace of mind. If you appreciate MSR's build quality but want something lighter than a Hubba Hubba without venturing into the realm of hyper-specialized ultralight tents, the FreeLite 2 is a smart, well-rounded choice that performs reliably on the trail. **Highlights** * Good balance of weight and MSR's proven durability * Semi-freestanding design is easy to pitch * Dual doors and good-sized vestibules * Effective ventilation for condensation control * Quality MSR construction provides peace of mind **Watch-outs** * Interior space can feel snug for two larger individuals * Requires careful staking at the foot end for full volume * Thinner fabrics require careful handling * Not as ultralight as some dedicated trekking pole shelters

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Half Dome SL 2+ versus FreeLite 2 specifications
SpecHalf Dome SL 2+FreeLite 2
MakerREI Co-opMSR
Capacity2+ person2 Person
DesignFreestanding, Double-Wall
Intended UseBackpacking, Car Camping
Packed DimensionsApprox. 8 x 20.5 inches
Season Rating3-Season
ModelFreeLite 2
Design TypeSemi-Freestanding Double Wall
Weight RangeLightweight Backpacking
Best Use3-Season Backpacking

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Half Dome SL 2+

  • Exceptional value for money; punches above its weight class
  • Generous interior space and vestibules for enhanced comfort
  • Robust freestanding design for easy pitching on any terrain
  • Durable materials and construction built to last many seasons
  • Excellent weather protection and condensation management
  • Heavier than true ultralight backpacking tents
  • Larger packed size compared to minimalist shelters
  • Ventilation can be less effective in extremely humid, still conditions

FreeLite 2

  • Excellent balance of weight, livability, and durability
  • MSR's proven quality construction and weather protection
  • Semi-freestanding design for easy and quick pitching
  • Dual doors and two spacious vestibules enhance comfort
  • Effective ventilation minimizes condensation issues
  • Interior can feel snug for two larger adults
  • Lighter fabrics require careful handling and a footprint
  • Not as light as dedicated ultralight trekking pole shelters
  • Requires proper staking at foot-end for full volume

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.