Best of the Best: Isabella Lake Loop (via Isabella Lake Entry Point 35) vs Numbered Lakes Loop (Entry Point 30, Lake One)
Isabella Lake Loop (via Isabella Lake Entry Point 35) vs Numbered Lakes Loop (Entry Point 30, Lake One)
Our #1 and #2 picks from Top 10 Flatwater Canoe Routes: Boundary Waters Multi-day, compared spec-by-spec with clear pros, cons, and a verdict.
Choosing a Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness (BWCAW) route is a crucial decision that shapes your entire wilderness experience. For those seeking classic Minnesota canoe country, two popular multi-day options are the Isabella Lake Loop (EP35) and the Numbered Lakes Loop (EP30, via Lake One). Both offer stunning scenery and excellent paddling, but they cater to slightly different skill levels and preferences. The Isabella Lake Loop is often celebrated for its rugged portages and diverse fishing opportunities, appealing to paddlers who embrace a more challenging, remote feel. In contrast, the Numbered Lakes Loop, starting from the heavily trafficked Lake One, provides a more accessible entry into the BWCAW with potentially more developed campsites and a quicker pace. This head-to-head comparison will dissect their key attributes to help you determine which of these iconic routes aligns best with your ideal paddling adventure.
Isabella Lake Loop (via Isabella Lake Entry Point 35)
Minnesota, USA
This loop is a classic for a reason, but it still maintains a more secluded feel than many central BWCA routes. The access from the south provides a gentler entry into the wilderness. Isabella Lake itself is large and can get choppy, but the surrounding smaller lakes and river sections offer sheltered paddling. You'll move through a mix of burned areas from the 2011 Pagami Creek fire and untouched forest, offering a unique perspective on wilderness regeneration. The portages here are generally well-maintained and on the shorter side, making it an excellent choice for a multi-day trip without excessive exertion. Wildlife is abundant, particularly moose and various bird species. The nearest town for supplies and outfitters is Isabella, though Ely or Grand Marais are larger hubs. Ideal season is late May to early October, with fall offering fewer bugs and stunning colors. Be prepared for black flies and mosquitos in early summer. Campsites are generally well-spaced, but planning for midweek travel helps avoid crowds.
Find it on AmazonNumbered Lakes Loop (Entry Point 30, Lake One)
Minnesota, USA
While Lake One is a popular entry point, sticking to the chain of Numbered Lakes (One, Two, Three, Four) and looping back offers a relatively easy flatwater experience with scenic beauty. The portages between these lakes are short and well-trodden, designed for easy travel. Once you get past Lake One, the crowds thin out, and the sense of wilderness grows. This route provides a good balance of accessibility and solitude. You'll find plenty of good campsites, often on islands, providing excellent views and privacy. The area is known for good fishing, particularly for walleye and northern pike. Nearest town is Ely. Peak season will see more traffic, so consider shoulder seasons for a quieter trip. Water levels are generally stable, but high winds can make the larger lakes challenging. This is an excellent choice for first-timers to the BWCA or families looking for a less strenuous adventure.
Find it on AmazonSpec-by-Spec
| Spec | #1 Isabella Lake Loop (via Isabella Lake Entry Point 35) | #2 Numbered Lakes Loop (Entry Point 30, Lake One) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Route Length | Approx. 25-30 miles | Approx. 20-25 miles |
| Average Trip Duration | 4-6 days | 3-5 days |
| Portage Difficulty | Moderate to Strenuous (several long/rugged) | Easy to Moderate (shorter, well-maintained) |
| Entry Point Number | Entry Point 35 (Isabella Lake) | Entry Point 30 (Lake One) |
| Permit Availability | Generally good, less competitive than EP30 | Highly competitive, requires early booking |
| Fishing Focus | Walleye, Northern Pike, Smallmouth Bass (known for good walleye) | Walleye, Northern Pike, Smallmouth Bass (good general fishing) |
| Solitude Level | Higher, especially deeper into the loop | Lower, especially near Lake One/Two/Three |
| Wildlife Viewing | Good potential for moose, bear, wolves, diverse birds | Good potential, but more human presence |
| Water Quality/Clarity | Excellent (often deeper, clearer lakes) | Excellent |
| Scenery Type | Rugged, boreal forest, varied lake sizes, rocky outcrops | Classic BWCAW, island-studded lakes, varied forest |
Isabella Lake Loop (via Isabella Lake Entry Point 35)
Best for: Experienced paddlers and anglers seeking solitude and a physical challenge.
Pros
- Greater sense of wilderness and solitude
- Excellent fishing opportunities, especially for walleye
- Challenging portages appeal to experienced paddlers
- Diverse scenery with varied lake types and forest
- Easier to secure permits due to lower demand
Cons
- More physically demanding due to longer/rougher portages
- Can feel remote, potentially less suitable for novices
- Longer drive to entry point for many visitors
- Fewer campsites available on some lakes
Numbered Lakes Loop (Entry Point 30, Lake One)
Best for: First-time BWCAW visitors, families, or groups desiring an accessible, classic canoe trip.
Pros
- More accessible entry point and generally shorter portages
- Ideal for first-time BWCAW visitors or families
- Well-established campsites with good amenities (latrines, fire grates)
- Efficient loop allows for a solid trip in fewer days
- Iconic BWCAW experience with classic scenery
Cons
- Very high competition for permits, requiring early planning
- Can be crowded, especially on the 'numbered' lakes
- Less sense of true solitude compared to more remote routes
- Initial sections can feel less 'wild'
The Verdict
For those seeking a more authentic, challenging BWCAW experience with a strong emphasis on solitude and diverse fishing, the Isabella Lake Loop is the clear winner. Its rugged portages and remote feel reward paddlers with a deeper sense of wilderness immersion and often better fishing. However, for first-timers, families, or groups prioritizing ease of access and shorter portages, the Numbered Lakes Loop takes the crown. While it can be busier, its well-maintained routes and accessible entry point make it an excellent introduction to the BWCAW. Ultimately, the choice depends on your group's experience level and desired wilderness intensity. If you crave a true test of grit and isolation, head to Isabella. If you want a classic, slightly gentler entry into canoe country, the Numbered Lakes will serve you well.