Best of the Best: MICROspikes vs Access Spike
MICROspikes vs Access Spike
Our #1 and #2 picks from The 10 Best Microspikes and Trail Traction Cleats of 2024, compared spec-by-spec with clear pros, cons, and a verdict.
When winter trails call, microspikes are an essential piece of gear, providing crucial traction on icy and snowy terrain. But not all microspikes are created equal, and choosing the right pair can significantly impact your safety and enjoyment. Today, we're putting two titans of trail traction head-to-head: Kahtoola's venerable MICROspikes and Black Diamond's Access Spike. Both brands are renowned for their quality and innovation in outdoor gear, but their approaches to microspike design offer distinct advantages and disadvantages. We'll delve into the specifics of each model, from their construction and weight to their intended use and overall performance, to help you determine which set of spikes will best serve your winter adventures. Whether you're a casual winter hiker or a serious mountaineer, understanding these differences is key to making an informed buying decision.
MICROspikes
Kahtoola
The Kahtoola MICROspikes are, for good reason, the benchmark in the category. They hit the sweet spot for the vast majority of winter hikers, backpackers, and even trail runners who encounter anything from icy sidewalks to moderately steep, frozen mountain trails. The stainless steel spikes, arranged strategically, bite securely into hard-packed snow and glaze ice. The elastomer harness is exceptionally robust and maintains its elasticity and grip even in brutal sub-zero temperatures, preventing slippage or coming off the boot. They're not the lightest, nor the most aggressive for true mountaineering, but for reliable, everyday winter traction, they are unmatched. They're built to last, often enduring seasons of heavy use with minimal wear, a testament to their solid construction and quality materials. While they can sometimes ball up with wet, sticky snow, it’s a minor inconvenience easily addressed with a quick stomp. For most, these are the only traction devices you’ll ever need. **Highlights** * 12 stainless steel spikes per foot provide excellent multi-directional traction. * Durable, reinforced elastomer harness remains supple and secure in cold. * Integrated toe bail and heel tab for easy donning and doffing. * Welded chains prevent stretch and offer robust connection to spikes. * Available in a wide range of sizes to fit most footwear. * Includes a sturdy tote sack for easy storage and transport. **Watch-outs** * Can accumulate sticky snow in certain conditions. * Heavier than some minimalist spike options. * Not suitable for technical vertical ice climbing.
Find it on AmazonAccess Spike
Black Diamond
Black Diamond's Access Spike is a strong contender for those who prioritize a lighter weight and more minimalist design without significantly compromising on grip. These spikes excel on icy approaches, mixed terrain, and moderately steep snowfields where every ounce counts. The front-point-like design of the steel spikes offers a surprisingly aggressive bite, particularly on uphill climbs. The elastomer harness is thinner and more pliable than some competitors, making them very packable and easy to stow in a small pocket or pack lid. While the harness isn't as beefy as the Kahtoola, it still holds up well to cold and secures firmly over a variety of boot shapes. They offer a good balance for fast-and-light missions or for those who only need traction intermittently. Durability is solid, though heavy, prolonged use on abrasive surfaces might show wear faster than more robust designs. **Highlights** * Aggressive 14-point spike configuration provides strong bite. * Ultralight design makes them highly packable and easy to carry. * Flexible elastomer harness conforms well to various footwear. * Welded chain links enhance durability and maintain spike positioning. * Integrated carry pouch included for protection and organization. **Watch-outs** * Slightly less secure fit than bulkier models on some boots. * Less robust construction might not hold up to extreme abuse as well. * Can still ball up with very wet snow.
Find it on AmazonSpec-by-Spec
| Spec | #1 MICROspikes | #2 Access Spike |
|---|---|---|
| Weight (pair, size M) | 11 oz (318 g) | 10.6 oz (300 g) |
| Capacity/Size | Fits men's US 7-10.5 / women's US 8.5-12 (size M) | Fits men's US 7.5-9.5 / women's US 8.5-10.5 (size M) |
| Materials | Hardened 400 series stainless steel spikes, reinforced elastomer harness | Stainless steel spikes, elastomeric harness |
| Price Tier | Premium | Mid-range |
| Warranty | 1-year against defects in materials and workmanship | Limited lifetime against defects in materials and workmanship |
| Best Use | Winter hiking, trail running, light mountaineering | Winter hiking, general trail traction |
| Portability | Good (includes tote sack) | Good (includes tote sack) |
| Durability | Excellent (renowned for longevity) | Very Good |
| Feature Highlights | 12 spikes per foot, patented reinforced eyelets, integrated toe bale | 14 spikes per foot, articulated front points, secure heel welt |
MICROspikes
Best for: Hikers and trail runners demanding maximum durability and reliable traction on varied, challenging winter terrain.
Pros
- Exceptional durability and longevity, a true workhorse.
- Reliable traction on varied icy and snowy terrain.
- Easy to put on and take off, even with gloves.
- Integrated toe bale for secure fit on a wider range of footwear.
Cons
- Can feel a bit heavier on longer, faster outings.
- Higher price point.
- Spikes are fixed, less articulation than some competitors.
Access Spike
Best for: Casual winter hikers seeking a lighter, more affordable option for general icy and snowy trail conditions.
Pros
- More spikes per foot for potentially better grip on certain surfaces.
- Articulated front points offer more natural foot flex.
- Lighter weight makes them slightly less noticeable.
- Generally more affordable, offering good value.
Cons
- Harness can be slightly less robust over long-term heavy use.
- Less aggressive traction than some heavy-duty options.
- Some users report less secure fit on certain boot types.
The Verdict
For overall performance, durability, and a truly bombproof design, the Kahtoola MICROspikes emerge as the clear winner. Their legendary toughness and reliable grip have made them a favorite among winter enthusiasts for good reason. While slightly heavier and more expensive, the investment pays off in peace of mind and longevity. The Black Diamond Access Spike is a commendable contender, offering a lighter, more agile feel with additional spikes for nuanced traction and a more attractive price point. However, their long-term durability and the absolute confidence they inspire on really challenging terrain don't quite match Kahtoola. Choose the MICROspikes if you prioritize maximum durability and unwavering grip on diverse winter adventures, while the Access Spike is a fantastic choice for those seeking a lighter, budget-friendly option for general winter hiking and less extreme conditions.