Skip to content

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Climbing Helmets head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Boreo

#6 on this list

Boreo

Petzl

The Petzl Boreo is built for maximum durability, utility, and cost efficiency. Serving as Petzl’s primary hardshell workhorse, the Boreo utilizes a thick ABS shell supported by a hybrid foam liner composed of both EPP and EPS. This makes it an ideal helmet for gym-to-crag climbers, institutional groups, and mountaineers seeking complete dependability without spending top-tier prices. Where the Boreo excels is overall coverage and daily resilience. It incorporates Petzl’s rigorous top-and-side protection design, dropping low around the ears and back of the head to defend against low-angle rock bounces and uncontrolled leader falls. Its thick ABS shell is practically impervious to the dings and squashing forces of stuffed backpacks, making it an excellent piece of kit for climbers who prefer not to baby their gear. At 10.6 ounces, the weight is noticeable when compared directly against hybrid foam models. The internal ventilation ports are smaller than those on higher-end helmets like the Meteor or Vision, resulting in a warmer microclimate on mid-summer ascents. However, for rugged durability at roughly $75, the trade-offs are entirely defensible. **Highlights** - Ultra-durable ABS outer shell resists rough handling - Hybrid EPP and EPS foam liner for enhanced energy absorption - Comprehensive side, rear, and top impact coverage - Simple, glove-friendly rear adjustment system - Accessible price point around $75 **Watch-outs** - Heavier profile at 10.6 ounces - Limited ventilation makes it run warm in direct sun

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Hardtop Climbing Helmet

#7 on this list

Hardtop Climbing Helmet

Metolius

The Metolius Hardtop is a straightforward, budget-conscious climbing helmet designed to deliver reliable protection without unnecessary complexity. Built around an injection-molded ABS outer shell backed by a traditional EPS foam core, it provides the standard impact protection needed for cragging, top-roping, and mountaineering on a modest gear budget. The helmet shines in its operational simplicity. The hard exterior shell easily withstands the rough-and-tumble nature of regular climbing travel, whether tossed into the trunk with a rack of cams or scraped against rough granite chimneys. A classic rear click-wheel dial makes adjusting the inner cradle effortless, allowing climbers to quickly alternate between a bare head and an insulating winter cap. Integrated clips secure standard headlamp straps securely for early alpine starts. Performance compromises are typical of entry-level hardshell designs. Weighing between 8.8 and 9.5 ounces, it is reasonably light for a full ABS helmet, but its EPS interior provides less multi-impact resilience than EPP construction. The ventilation apertures are relatively modest, meaning heat can build up during sustained, high-effort ascents under direct sunlight. **Highlights** - Tough injection-molded ABS plastic shell - Reliable internal EPS foam core for impact dissipation - Easy-to-use rear adjustment dial wheel - Secure headlamp attachment clips - Highly approachable price point **Watch-outs** - Modest ventilation limits breathability on hot days - EPS foam can only sustain a single severe impact

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Boreo versus Hardtop Climbing Helmet specifications
SpecBoreoHardtop Climbing Helmet
Weight10.6 oz (size S/M)—
Shell MaterialInjection-molded ABSInjection-molded ABS plastic
Liner ConstructionHybrid EPP and EPS foam—
Impact CertificationCE EN 12492, UIAA, Petzl Top and Side—
MSRPApproximately $75—
Headlamp AttachmentFour low-profile clips—
Impact Foam—Expanded polystyrene (EPS)
Weight Range—250-270 g / 8.8-9.5 oz
Size Range—52-58 cm, 58-61 cm
Suspension—Rear click-wheel dial
Headlamp Mounts—4 integrated retention clips

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Boreo

  • Thick ABS shell withstands rough pack transit and sharp debris without denting
  • Hybrid EPP and EPS foam liner provides thorough lateral and rear protection
  • Collapsible headband system packs down smoothly inside the helmet bowl
  • Exceptional long-term durability at an accessible retail price point
  • At 10.6 ounces, it feels heavy compared to modern all-foam alternatives
  • Modest vent openings trap heat during high-exertion climbs in direct sunlight

Hardtop Climbing Helmet

  • Durable ABS shell withstands rough pack transit and rock scrapes
  • Intuitive click-wheel harness operates smoothly with gloves
  • Approachable pricing lowers the cost barrier for newer climbers
  • Secure four-clip system holds headlamp bands firmly in place
  • Modest port size restricts airflow in hot, sunny conditions
  • EPS impact core must be retired after a single major blow
  • Heavier than higher-end all-foam climbing helmets

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.