Best of the Best: 220 Slug Gun vs Deerslayer III
220 Slug Gun vs Deerslayer III
Our #1 and #2 picks from The 10 Best Deer Hunting Shotguns, compared spec-by-spec with clear pros, cons, and a verdict.
Choosing the right slug gun can drastically impact your deer hunting success, especially in states where rifle use is restricted. This head-to-head comparison pits two titans of the slug gun world against each other: the precision-engineered Savage Arms 220 Slug Gun and the classic, pump-action Ithaca Deerslayer III. We'll delve into their features, performance, and ideal use cases to help you make an informed decision. Whether you prioritize repeatable accuracy at longer ranges or robust reliability in adverse conditions, understanding the nuances of each will guide you to the firearm that best suits your hunting style and local regulations. Let's break down which one will put venison in your freezer.
220 Slug Gun
Savage Arms
A bolt action with an AccuTrigger and a rifled 20-gauge barrel. The most accurate factory slug gun made.
Find it on AmazonDeerslayer III
Ithaca Gun Company
Barrel pinned to the receiver, not clamped. Legendary for two-inch groups at 100 yards.
Find it on AmazonSpec-by-Spec
| Spec | #1 220 Slug Gun | #2 Deerslayer III |
|---|---|---|
| Weight | Approx. 7.5 lbs | Approx. 7.5 lbs (12 ga) / 7.25 lbs (20 ga) |
| Capacity/Size | 2+1 (detachable box magazine) | 4+1 (tubular magazine) |
| Materials | Carbon steel receiver, synthetic stock, blued barrel | Milled steel receiver, walnut or synthetic stock, blued barrel |
| Price Tier | Mid-high (typically $700-$900) | High (typically $1,000-$1,300) |
| Warranty | Limited Lifetime Warranty | Limited Lifetime Warranty |
| Best Use | Long-range precision slug hunting (100-200 yards) | Brush hunting, versatile close-to-medium range, reliability |
| Portability | Good, balances well for carrying | Good, traditional feel and balance |
| Durability | Very good, robust bolt action | Excellent, all-steel construction |
| Feature Highlights | AccuTrigger, free-floating rifled barrel, detachable box mag, scope rail | Bottom ejecting, fixed barrel, integral Weaver rail, classic design |
220 Slug Gun
Best for: Hunters demanding rifle-like accuracy and extended range in slug-restricted areas.
Pros
- Exceptional accuracy at longer ranges for a slug gun
- Adjustable AccuTrigger allows for a crisp, light pull
- Detachable box magazine for quick reloads
- Bolt-action reliability and simplicity
- Often more affordable than the Deerslayer III
Cons
- Limited to 20-gauge only (no 12-gauge option)
- Bolt action is slower for follow-up shots
- Synthetic stock might feel less traditional to some hunters
- Detachable magazine can be lost or prone to feeding issues if dirty
Deerslayer III
Best for: Traditionalists seeking unparalleled reliability and craftsmanship for close-to-medium range hunting.
Pros
- Legendary reliability and smooth pump action
- Bottom ejection keeps spent shells clear of face and vision
- All-steel construction for extreme durability
- Fixed barrel ensures consistent accuracy
- Iconic and classic American firearm design
Cons
- Significantly higher price point
- Pump action is generally less accurate than a bolt action at extended ranges
- Heavier and bulkier feel compared to some modern options
- Capacity is lower than some traditional shotguns (but standard for slug guns)
The Verdict
For the modern deer hunter prioritizing precision and maximizing effective range in slug-only zones, the **Savage Arms 220 Slug Gun** emerges as the clear winner. Its bolt-action platform, combined with the AccuTrigger and rifled barrel, delivers rifle-like accuracy that is unparalleled in the slug gun category, making clean, ethical shots at 150-200 yards achievable. While the Ithaca Deerslayer III is a marvel of engineering, known for its legendary reliability and robust build, its pump-action mechanism inherently limits its accuracy potential compared to the Savage. The Ithaca shines in its durability and classic feel, but the Savage 220 offers a significant performance edge where accuracy is paramount, and its lower price point is a bonus. If you value sub-2-inch groups at 100 yards, the Savage is your best bet.