Best of the Best: Pocket Gill Net vs ASE Survival Gill Net
Pocket Gill Net vs ASE Survival Gill Net
Our #1 and #2 picks from The 10 Best Survival Gill Nets, compared spec-by-spec with clear pros, cons, and a verdict.
For those preparing for the unexpected, or simply looking to add a crucial foraging tool to their wilderness kit, gill nets offer a compact and effective way to secure protein. In this head-to-head, we're pitting two popular miniature gill nets against each other: the Pocket Gill Net from 5col Survival Supply and the ASE Survival Gill Net from Best Glide Aviation Survival Equipment (ASE). Both are designed to be lightweight and portable, making them ideal for emergency or survival scenarios where space and weight are at a premium. The key question for preppers and outdoor enthusiasts is which of these nets provides the better balance of durability, effectiveness, and ease of use in a pinch. We'll delve into their specifications, highlight their strengths and weaknesses, and ultimately help you decide which one deserves a spot in your essential gear.
Pocket Gill Net
5col Survival Supply
A 23-foot-long gill net that fits in a cargo pocket and weighs only five ounces. The 1.5-inch square mesh is sized for eating fish, and the integral top and bottom strings make it a true ready-to-fish package. American-made and the most versatile length in the test.
Visit productASE Survival Gill Net
Best Glide ASE
The survival-gill-net standard used in aviation and wilderness kits. A 12 ft x 4 ft monofilament net with 1.5-inch survival mesh, weighted foot rope and floating top rope so it hangs correctly without extra rigging. Meets current FAA guidance and doubles as a small-game snare.
Visit productSpec-by-Spec
| Spec | #1 Pocket Gill Net | #2 ASE Survival Gill Net |
|---|---|---|
| Weight | Not published | Not published |
| Capacity/Size | 6' L x 4' H (approx) | 12' L x 4' H (approx) |
| Materials | Monofilament line, unknown denier | Monofilament nylon |
| Price Tier | Low-Mid | Mid |
| Warranty | Not published | Not published |
| Best Use | Compact survival kit, minimalist foraging | Survival/emergency fishing, larger protein acquisition |
| Portability | Extremely compact, fits in altoids tin | Compact, slightly larger than A |
| Durability | Moderate (fine monofilament) | Moderate (monofilament, potentially thicker) |
| Feature Highlights | Integrated float and lead lines, small mesh | Weighted lead line, float line included, larger coverage area |
Pocket Gill Net
Best for: Ultra-minimalist survival kits and urban emergency caches where space is critically limited.
Pros
- Extremely compact and lightweight, ideal for minimalist kits.
- Very affordable, making it easy to include as a 'just in case' item.
- Small mesh size is good for catching smaller fish species.
Cons
- Smaller size limits potential catch volume.
- Fine monofilament can be prone to tangling and damage.
- No specific mention of line strength or durability details.
ASE Survival Gill Net
Best for: Dedicated survivalists and preppers prioritizing effectiveness and catch potential in a wilderness emergency.
Pros
- Twice the length, offering greater coverage and potential catch.
- Comes with both lead and float lines, ready for deployment.
- Reputable brand in survival gear, suggesting thoughtful design.
Cons
- Higher price point for a single-use or emergency item.
- Still relatively delicate, requiring careful handling.
- Specific line denier/strength is not readily available.
The Verdict
For overall effectiveness and a higher probability of success in a survival situation, the **ASE Survival Gill Net** emerges as the clear winner. Its double length provides a significant advantage, increasing your chances of catching fish in a larger area, which is crucial when sustenance is paramount. While both nets utilize monofilament and require careful handling to avoid tangles and damage, the ASE's larger size directly translates to greater utility in a dire situation. The 5col Pocket Gill Net, while incredibly compact and affordable, is best suited for scenarios where space is the ultimate constraint and very small fish are the primary target. For any serious survival kit aiming for efficient protein acquisition, the ASE's extended coverage makes it the more reliable choice, even with its slightly higher price. Consider your specific survival strategy and target species when making your final decision.