Best of the Best: Base Camp 6 Tent vs Redcliff Light
Base Camp 6 Tent vs Redcliff Light
Our #1 and #2 picks from The 10 Best Car Camping Tents for Roomy Family and Basecamp Adventures, compared spec-by-spec with clear pros, cons, and a verdict.
Choosing the right large tent can make or break your group camping experience. Today, we're pitting two distinct titans against each other: the REI Co-op Base Camp 6 Tent, a beloved car camping staple, and the Seek Outside Redcliff Light, a versatile backcountry-to-basecamp shelter. This comparison isn't just about capacity; it's about evaluating comfort, weather resistance, portability, and long-term value against different camping styles. Whether you prioritize easy setup and family-friendly features or rugged durability and four-season performance in a lighter package, understanding their core differences is key to making an informed decision for your next outdoor adventure.
Base Camp 6 Tent
REI Co-op
The REI Co-op Base Camp 6 is our top pick for families and groups who prioritize robust weather protection and excellent livability. This tent doesn't mess around; it's built to withstand a serious storm while offering generous headroom and floor space for up to six people, though we think it's most comfortable for four to five with gear. The two large D-shaped doors, each with a vestibule, make entry and exit smooth, even with multiple campers. Construction is REI's standard high quality, featuring burly aluminum poles that laugh at strong winds and a full-coverage rainfly designed to shed torrential downpours. The tent body itself is a blend of breathable mesh and durable ripstop nylon, striking a good balance between ventilation and privacy. While it's certainly not light, at around 20 pounds, that weight translates directly into stability and peace of mind when the weather turns. Setup, while involving a few more poles than some, is intuitive thanks to color-coded clips and webbing. Its nearly vertical walls maximize interior volume, giving it a much roomier feel than its footprint might suggest. This tent is a long-term investment for serious car campers. **Highlights** * Superior weather protection with full-coverage rainfly and strong poles. * Near-vertical walls create exceptional interior volume and headroom. * Two large doors and vestibules for easy access and gear storage. * Ample ventilation with mesh panels and adjustable rainfly vents. * Durable construction with robust fabrics and aluminum poles. **Watch-outs** * Heavier and bulkier packed size compared to some competitors. * Higher price point, though justified by durability. * Setup takes a bit longer due to multiple poles.
Find it on Amazon
Spec-by-Spec
| Spec | #1 Base Camp 6 Tent | #2 Redcliff Light |
|---|---|---|
| Weight | 20 lbs. 10 oz. (Packed) | 6 lbs. 10 oz. (Tent body & poles, packed minimum) |
| Capacity/Size | 6 person; 83.3 sq. ft. floor area, 74 in. peak height | 4-6 person; 81 sq. ft. floor area, 69 in. peak height |
| Materials | Canopy: 75D polyester taffeta; Fly: 75D polyester taffeta; Floor: 150D polyester oxford | 30D Cordura Ripstop Nylon (silnylon) |
| Price Tier | Mid-range (~$500) | Premium / High-end (~$800, tent only) |
| Warranty | REI Co-op's 1-year satisfaction guarantee | Lifetime against defects in materials and workmanship |
| Best Use | Car camping, family camping, fair-weather base camps | Backcountry hunting, winter camping, expedition base camps, hot tenting |
| Portability | Low (heavy, bulky for car camping only) | High (can be packed for backpacking or sledding) |
| Durability | Good for car camping, polyester materials | Excellent, Cordura ripstop nylon, designed for extreme conditions |
| Feature Highlights | Easy setup, 2 large doors, multiple vents, internal pockets, pole repair kit, footprint included | Stove jack compatible (requires stove), trekking pole setup option, highly wind-resistant, pyramid/tipi design |
Base Camp 6 Tent
Best for: Families and groups seeking an affordable, spacious, and easy-to-use tent for car camping in mild to moderate weather.
Pros
- Excellent value for a spacious, feature-rich car camping tent
- Very easy and intuitive setup, even for beginners
- Generous peak height and floor area for comfortable standing and sleeping
- Includes footprint, saving an additional purchase
- Good ventilation for warm weather
Cons
- Too heavy and bulky for any form of backpacking
- Less resistant to extreme weather compared to 4-season tents
- Polyester fabric is not as light or robust as some premium materials
- Limited seasonality (best for 3-season car camping)
Redcliff Light
Best for: Experienced backcountry users, hunters, and winter campers prioritizing ultralight durability, four-season performance, and hot tent capability.
Pros
- Exceptional strength-to-weight ratio, suitable for backpacking
- Four-season capable, excels in high winds and snow loads
- Stove jack allows for comfortable hot tenting in cold conditions
- Versatile setup with trekking poles or dedicated poles
- Highly durable Cordura fabric for long-term abuse
Cons
- Much higher price point, especially if adding a stove and inner tent
- No built-in floor; requires ground sheet or inner tent for protection
- Single-wall design can lead to condensation without proper ventilation or stove
- Setup takes practice, especially in adverse conditions
The Verdict
The REI Co-op Base Camp 6 and Seek Outside Redcliff Light are excellent tents, but for entirely different purposes. The clear winner for casual, family-oriented car camping is the **REI Co-op Base Camp 6 Tent**. It offers incredible value, straightforward setup, and ample space for a fraction of the cost. However, if your adventures involve pushing into the backcountry, enduring harsh winter conditions, or requiring the warmth of a wood stove, the **Seek Outside Redcliff Light** is the undisputed champion. Its robust construction, low weight for its size, and four-season capability make it a specialized, top-tier choice for serious outdoor enthusiasts willing to invest. Choose wisely based on your actual camping style.