Best of the Best: LCD Breeder Hen vs LCD Quarter Strut Jake
LCD Breeder Hen vs LCD Quarter Strut Jake
Our #1 and #2 picks from The 10 Best Turkey Decoys, compared spec-by-spec with clear pros, cons, and a verdict.
Choosing the right turkey decoy can dramatically impact your success in the field, turning a quiet morning into an unforgettable hunt. For turkey enthusiasts, Avian-X's LCD (Lifelike Collapsible Decoy) series stands out for its realism and effectiveness. We're pitting two popular Avian-X options against each other: the LCD Breeder Hen and the LCD Quarter Strut Jake. Both are designed to lure in gobblers, but they do so with different visual cues and implied behaviors. Understanding their nuances is key to selecting the decoy that best fits your hunting strategy, whether you're targeting dominant Toms early in the season or trying to draw in a wary gobbler later on. This comparison will help you decide which avian artist will complete your turkey hunting masterpiece.
LCD Breeder Hen
Avian-X
The submissive hen posture that pulls gobblers the last twenty yards — the most useful single decoy made.
Buy on AmazonLCD Quarter Strut Jake
Avian-X
Paired with the breeder hen, this jake triggers dominant gobblers without the flare risk of a full strutter.
Buy on AmazonSpec-by-Spec
| Spec | #1 LCD Breeder Hen | #2 LCD Quarter Strut Jake |
|---|---|---|
| Product Name | Avian-X LCD Breeder Hen | Avian-X LCD Quarter Strut Jake |
| Category | Turkey Decoy (Hen) | Turkey Decoy (Jake) |
| Pose/Behavior | Breeding/Receptive Hen | Dominant Young Male (Quarter Strut) |
| Weight | Approx. 2.5 lbs (with stake) | Approx. 2.7 lbs (with stake) |
| Size (Approx.) | Lifesize Hen (approx. 24" long) | Lifesize Jake (approx. 28" long from head to tail fan) |
| Materials | Durable, collapsible rubber/foam blend | Durable, collapsible rubber/foam blend |
| Price Tier | Mid-to-High | Mid-to-High |
| Warranty | Not published (Standard Avian-X likely) | Not published (Standard Avian-X likely) |
| Best Use | Enticing dominant gobblers, solo or with jake/tom decoys | Challenging dominant gobblers, especially effective with hens |
| Portability | Highly portable (collapsible, lightweight) | Highly portable (collapsible, lightweight) |
| Durability | Excellent (holds shape, weather resistant) | Excellent (holds shape, weather resistant) |
| Feature Highlights | Natural, soft-touch material, realistic paint scheme, includes stake, collapsible | Natural, soft-touch material, realistic paint scheme, includes stake, collapsible, detachable fan holder |
LCD Breeder Hen
Best for: Hunters seeking a realistic, passive hen decoy to entice gobblers without aggression, or to complete a breeding setup.
Pros
- Ultra-realistic hen pose, mimicking receptiveness.
- Excellent for luring in dominant gobblers looking for a mate.
- Versatile in various setups (solo, with jake, with full tom).
- Compact and lightweight for easy transport.
Cons
- May not always trigger a confrontational response from wary gobblers.
- Can be less effective in areas with high hunting pressure.
- Requires careful positioning to convey desired receptiveness.
LCD Quarter Strut Jake
Best for: Hunters aiming to directly challenge dominant gobblers and provoke an aggressive, territorial response.
Pros
- Aggressive posture challenges dominant gobblers directly.
- Highly effective when paired with a hen decoy to simulate breeding.
- Detachable fan holder allows for use with real or artificial fan.
- Very realistic, often provoking an aggressive response from Toms.
Cons
- Aggressive posture can sometimes scare off very wary or subordinate gobblers.
- Larger profile when carrying if fan is attached (though detachable).
- Potentially attracts other jakes or subordinate toms, which may not be the target.
The Verdict
For hunters seeking to provoke an aggressive, territorial response from gobblers, the **Avian-X LCD Quarter Strut Jake** emerges as the clear winner. Its challenging posture, especially when paired with a hen, is a potent trigger for mature Toms looking to assert dominance. However, its confrontational nature might deter extremely wary birds or subordinate gobblers. The Avian-X LCD Breeder Hen, while highly realistic and effective, plays a more passive role, aiming to entice rather than provoke. It's an excellent choice for a more subtle approach or when hunting pressured birds. Ultimately, the Jake offers a more direct and often more thrilling interaction for those seeking a fight. Choose the Jake for high-action hunts, and the Breeder Hen for finesse or pairing in a complex setup.