Skip to content

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Water Shoes head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
3T Barefoot Max Water Shoe

#10 on this list

3T Barefoot Max Water Shoe

Body Glove

The Body Glove 3T Barefoot Max is an entry-level aqua sock tailored for casual water recreation, paddleboarding, and sandy beach entries. Its standout design element is the three-toe pocket configuration, which separates your big toe and second toe while grouping the remaining small toes together, promoting natural foot articulation and balance on paddleboards and floating docks. The upper is constructed from a lightweight, stretch-neoprene and mesh combination that slips on easily and relies on an adjustable velcro strap across the instep for tensioning. An integrated drainage system runs through the bottom of the sole, allowing water to drain out the bottom when you step out of the water. For swimmers, casual tubers, and stand-up paddleboarders who just need defense against hot sand, broken shells, or boat ramp slime, it works adequately. This shoe is not built for serious river running, portaging, or technical wading. The ultra-thin sole offers virtually zero puncture defense against sharp river spikes or jagged rocks, and heavy pack carries will quickly bruise your feet. Additionally, the soft sole and basic strap system cannot handle suction mud; stepping into deep shoreline muck will easily rip the shoe from your foot or fill the toe pockets with debris. **Highlights** * Patented three-toe design promotes balance and natural articulation on boards * Integrated sole drainage system lets water evacuate quickly * Stretch neoprene and mesh upper provides a close, sock-like fit * Lightweight and highly packable, taking up minimal room in day bags * Very affordable option for casual, low-impact water activities **Watch-outs** * Not suitable for portages, rocky trail hiking, or heavy load carries * Soft construction pulls off easily in deep river suction mud * Minimal sole thickness offers little protection from sharp underwater obstacles

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Newport H2

#1 on this list

Newport H2

Keen

The Keen Newport H2 is the indisputable benchmark for rough portages and rocky coastlines. If your paddling involves stepping out of an aluminum canoe onto slick, jagged limestone while carrying a heavy barrel pack, this is the shoe you want on your feet. Its oversized, wraparound rubber toe bumper provides the best frontal impact protection in the category, guarding against hidden stumps and submerged rocks that would easily break a toe in a standard sandal. Underfoot, the Newport delivers a stiff, supportive platform with multi-directional lugs and razor siping that bites into wet surfaces. The polyester webbing upper is backed with a quick-drying hydrophobic mesh lining that sits comfortably against bare skin without creating friction blisters when grit inevitably slips in. The bungee lace system pulls the entire chassis tight across the instep, keeping your foot planted securely over the molded footbed even when trudging through thick marsh muck. Its strengths are also its trade-offs. The thick materials and robust sole add noticeable weight compared to modern minimalist river shoes. Once completely soaked, the padded webbing takes considerably longer to dry out than bare webbing or single-layer mesh shoes, meaning you will often put on a damp shoe the second morning of an expedition. It also tends to trap small pebbles beneath your heel until you manually take it off to rinse it. **Highlights** * Massive patented rubber toe bumper for superior impact protection * Razor-siped, non-marking outsole provides dependable wet-surface traction * Washable polyester webbing with quick-drying lining * Secure bungee lace capture system for easy one-pull fit adjustment * Supportive, contoured EVA footbed with arch support **Watch-outs** * Heavy and bulky compared to modern hybrid water shoes * Traps fine gravel and river pebbles underfoot, requiring removal to clear * Dense webbing and padding take a long time to dry overnight

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

3T Barefoot Max Water Shoe versus Newport H2 specifications
Spec3T Barefoot Max Water ShoeNewport H2
Upper MaterialStretch neoprene with breathable mesh panelsWashable polyester webbing with quick-dry lining
OutsoleThin molded rubber with drainage channelsNon-marking rubber with razor siping
Closure SystemHook-and-loop instep strap with pull tab—
Toe ConfigurationThree-pocket barefoot layout—
Drainage StyleDirect through-the-sole water ports—
Intended TerrainPaddleboards, docks, sandy shores, flat water—
Weight Per Shoe—14.2 oz (402 g) for men's US 9
Midsole—Compression-molded EVA
Closure—Lace-lock bungee capture system
Arch Profile—Contoured metatomical footbed support

What our reviewers liked and didn't

3T Barefoot Max Water Shoe

  • Three-toe design improves balance and tactile board feel on paddleboards
  • Through-the-sole drainage ports quickly purge water on exits
  • Lightweight, flexible construction packs down flat in small dry bags
  • Affordable entry point for casual beach, dock, and lake use
  • Zero midsole protection against sharp rocks or heavy portage loads
  • Suction mud easily pulls the shoe off the foot
  • Inadequate traction on slimy, algae-covered river cobblestones

Newport H2

  • Unmatched rubber toe bumper shields feet against hidden boulders and logs
  • Stiff, supportive midsole handles heavy pack weights on rocky portages
  • Razor-siped rubber outsole grips wet rock and slick riverbeds reliably
  • Durable polyester webbing and burly construction survive years of abuse
  • Noticeably heavy and bulky, especially when thoroughly waterlogged
  • Thick webbing and padded lining take hours to dry overnight
  • Open side cutouts let river gravel and small stones trap underfoot

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.