Skip to content
Wild10

Become a contributor

Join

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Sierra Golden Trout Lakes head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Puppet Lake

#7 on this list

Puppet Lake

Sierra National Forest, California

Positioned at 11,160 feet in the French Canyon region of Humphreys Basin, Puppet Lake is widely regarded by backcountry anglers as one of the most productive golden trout waters in the central Sierra. The lake sits in a rugged granite trough with dramatic cliffs dropping straight into cold, deep water along its southern shore, while the northern edge features accessible gravel bars and boulder points. Puppet Lake benefits from an ideal combination of depth, surface area, and wind-driven food circulation. It holds a self-sustaining population of goldens that feed heavily on callibaetis mayflies and midge pupae along the shallow shelves. Fish here routinely hit the 10- to 12-inch mark with exceptional girth and coloration, showing vivid gold flanks speckled with dense, dark spots and clean, white-edged ventral fins. The hike in begins at North Lake Trailhead, climbing over 11,400-foot Piute Pass into the sprawling tundra of Humphreys Basin. From the main trail in French Canyon, anglers break off on unmaintained cross-country routes, climbing over granite ramps and through fractured gullies to gain Puppet Lake's secluded bowl. The open landscape provides zero tree cover, requiring anglers to stalk carefully to avoid casting long shadows over cruising fish.

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Cottonwood Lake #5

#8 on this list

Cottonwood Lake #5

Inyo National Forest, California

Cottonwood Lake #5 is ground zero for California golden trout management. Resting at 11,200 feet in the Cottonwood Lakes Basin, this lake was historically tapped by the state of California as the primary wild broodstock source used to establish golden trout fisheries across the western United States. Because of this management history, the fish here remain pure-strain specimens of unrivaled pedigree. The lake sits in a wide, high-alpine granite basin surrounded by low turf meadows and scree slopes beneath Mount Langley. It offers deep, clear water with large underwater granite slabs where fish cruise in predictable patterns. While fishing pressure is higher here than in the off-trail lakes deeper in the range, strict barbless and gear restrictions have maintained an abundant population of goldens that display textbook golden-yellow and scarlet color profiles. Access is straightforward compared to other waters on this list: a well-trodden, six-mile trail out of Horseshoe Meadow leads directly to the Cottonwood chain. Lake #5 sits in the upper tier of the basin, requiring just a short walk past Lakes #1 through #4. It is the premier destination for anglers seeking pure-strain golden trout without committing to high-hazard mountaineering or off-trail navigation.

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Puppet Lake versus Cottonwood Lake #5 specifications
SpecPuppet LakeCottonwood Lake #5
Elevation11,160 feet11,200 feet
Primary FishGolden trout (self-sustaining)—
TrailheadNorth Lake (Piute Pass Trail)Horseshoe Meadow (Cottonwood Lakes Trail)
One-Way DistanceApprox. 13 to 14 miles—
JurisdictionSierra National Forest / John Muir Wilderness—
Required GearApproved hard-sided bear canister—
Hiking Distance—6.0 miles one-way
Elevation Gain—1,200 feet from trailhead
Primary Quarry—Pure-strain California golden trout
Managing Agency—Inyo National Forest / Golden Trout Wilderness

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Puppet Lake

  • Productive fishery with wild, brilliantly colored golden trout
  • Excellent sight-fishing opportunities along shallow northern gravel shelves
  • Far less foot traffic than the heavily used trails of Humphreys Basin
  • Unobstructed high-alpine panoramic views of the French Canyon peaks
  • Zero natural timber for wind protection or shelter from storms
  • Requires strenuous off-trail cross-country navigation with a full pack
  • Short fishable season due to high elevation and persistent snowpack

Cottonwood Lake #5

  • Historic pure-strain golden trout genetics in their native high basin
  • Gentle, well-marked trail access starting from a 10,000-foot trailhead
  • Superb sight fishing along clear granite shelves and drop-offs
  • Convenient staging area for non-technical summits of Mount Langley
  • Substantial camping and angling pressure compared to off-trail lakes
  • High winds and barren shorelines offer zero protection from afternoon storms
  • Strict seasonal closures cut short early summer angling opportunities

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.