Skip to content
Wild10

Become a contributor

Join

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Sierra Golden Trout Lakes head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Royce Lake #2

#4 on this list

Royce Lake #2

Sierra National Forest, California

The Royce Lakes Basin sits suspended above French Canyon at roughly 11,700 feet, a stark, windswept granite plateau containing five distinct lakes. Royce Lake #2 is the crown jewel of the basin, featuring profound water depth, sheer talus borders, and a self-sustaining population of golden trout that regularly out-measures fish found in neighboring drainages. The water holds a striking turquoise tint caused by ultra-fine glacial flour and extreme depth. Because the lake drops off steeply within feet of the shoreline, adult goldens have space to retreat into cold sanctuary zones during the heat of late August. The trout cruise the narrow littoral fringe hunting for chironomids and caddis larvae, then slip back into the dark blue depths when startled. Anglers who stay low against the white granite boulders and fish long, light fluorocarbon leaders (6x or 7x) can sight-fish to heavy, deep-bodied trout pushing 12 to 14 inches. Reaching Royce Lake #2 requires departing the Pine Creek Pass Trail near the pass summit and ascending a steep, trackless cross-country ramp over loose talus and slick bedrock. The approach from the Owens Valley side involves climbing out of the Pine Creek Trailhead, conquering over 4,000 feet of switchbacks past old tungsten mines. It is an exhausting trek that filters out all but the most dedicated backcountry fly fishers.

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Hitchcock Lakes

#5 on this list

Hitchcock Lakes

Sequoia National Park, California

Sitting quietly beneath the massive western wall of Mount Hitchcock and directly across from Mount Whitney, the Hitchcock Lakes lie at 11,570 feet in an austere granite cirque. While hundreds of hikers march up the nearby Mount Whitney Trail daily, almost none make the off-trail descent into the Hitchcock Basin. The lower lake is massive, exceptionally deep, and fed by permanent snowfields clinging to the 13,000-foot ridgelines above. The golden trout in Hitchcock are historically derived from early Whitney-area stockings and have adapted brilliantly to the lake's sheer, cold profile. Due to the deep water and stable subsurface insect life, the fish exhibit thick shoulders and saturated vermillion bellies. Unlike fish in shallow tarns that stunt at six inches, Hitchcock goldens often reach solid foot-long lengths, patrolling the shoreline drop-offs in small pods during calm morning hours. Access requires securing a highly competitive Mount Whitney Trail permit or an Inyo National Forest wilderness permit over Trail Crest via Cottonwood. From the Whitney Trail near Guitar Lake, you must leave the path and navigate cross-country across stepped granite benches and boulder fields. Wind is a near-constant factor here, rippling the surface and testing casting accuracy, but when the surface calms, the sight-fishing is world-class.

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Royce Lake #2 versus Hitchcock Lakes specifications
SpecRoyce Lake #2Hitchcock Lakes
ElevationApproximately 11,740 feet11,570 feet
Managing AgencySierra National Forest / Inyo National Forest—
Primary TrailheadPine Creek Pack Station (Rounds Valley)—
Round-Trip DistanceRoughly 18 to 22 miles depending on route—
Target SpeciesCalifornia golden trout (Oncorhynchus aguabonita)—
Best WindowMid-July through late SeptemberMid-July through early September
Location—Sequoia National Park, California
Fish Species—California Golden Trout
Access—Off-trail route from Mount Whitney Trail
Permit Agency—Inyo National Forest / NPS

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Royce Lake #2

  • Supports significantly larger golden trout than surrounding high-altitude waters
  • Spectacular high-alpine amphitheater with stunning turquoise water clarity
  • Cross-country access filters out casual day hikers and ensures solitude
  • Abundant daylight cruising along sheer granite shorelines allows prime sight-fishing
  • Exhausting approach with more than 4,000 vertical feet of climbing
  • Virtually no shelter from howling winds, hail, and high-altitude lightning
  • Extremely limited flat ground for setting up tents without rock interference

Hitchcock Lakes

  • True backcountry solitude within a mile of the crowded Whitney corridor
  • Consistently larger golden trout than found in typical Sierra timberline tarns
  • Exceptional sight-fishing opportunities along clear granite drop-offs
  • Unmatched high-alpine scenery beneath the sheer face of Mount Hitchcock
  • Navigating competitive permit quotas requires extensive forward planning
  • Near-constant high winds frequently impede delicate fly-line delivery
  • Completely exposed granite basin offers zero protection from severe weather

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.