
Reader rating
Rate it and you move it. Community ratings re-rank this product inside its Top 10 list.
Expert-picked, reader-ranked. Our editors choose the products and the launch order; member star ratings move picks up or down over time.
The Royce Lakes Basin sits suspended above French Canyon at roughly 11,700 feet, a stark, windswept granite plateau containing five distinct lakes. Royce Lake #2 is the crown jewel of the basin, featuring profound water depth, sheer talus borders, and a self-sustaining population of golden trout that regularly out-measures fish found in neighboring drainages. The water holds a striking turquoise tint caused by ultra-fine glacial flour and extreme depth. Because the lake drops off steeply within feet of the shoreline, adult goldens have space to retreat into cold sanctuary zones during the heat of late August. The trout cruise the narrow littoral fringe hunting for chironomids and caddis larvae, then slip back into the dark blue depths when startled. Anglers who stay low against the white granite boulders and fish long, light fluorocarbon leaders (6x or 7x) can sight-fish to heavy, deep-bodied trout pushing 12 to 14 inches. Reaching Royce Lake #2 requires departing the Pine Creek Pass Trail near the pass summit and ascending a steep, trackless cross-country ramp over loose talus and slick bedrock. The approach from the Owens Valley side involves climbing out of the Pine Creek Trailhead, conquering over 4,000 feet of switchbacks past old tungsten mines. It is an exhausting trek that filters out all but the most dedicated backcountry fly fishers.
Pros
- Supports significantly larger golden trout than surrounding high-altitude waters
- Spectacular high-alpine amphitheater with stunning turquoise water clarity
- Cross-country access filters out casual day hikers and ensures solitude
- Abundant daylight cruising along sheer granite shorelines allows prime sight-fishing
Cons
- Exhausting approach with more than 4,000 vertical feet of climbing
- Virtually no shelter from howling winds, hail, and high-altitude lightning
- Extremely limited flat ground for setting up tents without rock interference
Best uses
- Stalking trophy backcountry goldens
- Advanced cross-country alpine backpacking
- High-elevation photography and scrambling
- Multi-day High Sierra fly fishing circuits
Specifications
- Elevation
- Approximately 11,740 feet
- Managing Agency
- Sierra National Forest / Inyo National Forest
- Primary Trailhead
- Pine Creek Pack Station (Rounds Valley)
- Round-Trip Distance
- Roughly 18 to 22 miles depending on route
- Target Species
- California golden trout (Oncorhynchus aguabonita)
- Best Window
- Mid-July through late September
Best for
Stalking trophy backcountry goldens, Advanced cross-country alpine backpacking, High-elevation photography and scrambling, Multi-day High Sierra fly fishing circuits
Tucked away on an austere granite bench high above French Canyon, Royce Lake #2 occupies a harsh moonscape at 11,700 feet. The Royce Basin holds five distinct tarns, but the second lake stands apart for its sheer depth, electric turquoise tint, and deep-bodied golden trout. Surrounded by fractured moraines, scree fields, and the towering bulk of the Royce Peaks and Merriam Peak, there is virtually no vegetation to break the wind or soften the landscape. It is stark Sierra wilderness at its most unvarnished. Reaching this water demands significant physical effort, whether grinding up the steep eastern escarpment from Pine Creek or bushwhacking over passes from the west. The lake drops off sharply right along its granite margins, creating an environment where trout can feed in shallow margins before diving into cold, dark abyss zones. This bathymetry produces fish that grow larger and sturdier than the stunted populations typical of cramped alpine tarns. Exposure is absolute here. Campers find few level spots among the scree, fire bans are permanent, and sudden storms turn the bare rock into a lightning trap. For backcountry anglers who do not mind long approaches, boulder-hopping with a loaded pack, and technical sight-fishing on ultra-clear water, Royce Lake #2 offers one of the finest wild trout experiences in the High Sierra.
Terrain and Hydrology
Royce Lake #2 rests in an alpine hanging valley hollowed out by glacial action, bound by massive talus aprons and polished granodiorite slabs. The lake water owes its brilliant blue-green color to extreme clarity, depth, and trace glacial silt carried down from late-melting snowfields beneath the ridgelines. There are almost no soft shores; the margins are composed of angular granite boulders, bedrock drop-offs, and narrow gravel shelves. Because the basin sits well north of 11,500 feet, true soil is absent, meaning zero tree cover exists around the shoreline. The lake drains westward toward French Canyon, feeding a series of lower tarns, but Lake #2 remains the deepest and most ecologically stable water in the chain.
Weather Windows and Timing
Snow hangs on tenaciously in the Royce Basin well into summer. Ice-out rarely completes before early July, and in heavy snow years, solid slush and drifting bergs can linger into August. The ideal fishing and travel window opens around mid-July and runs through the first heavy autumn dusting in late September. Summer afternoons regularly bring thermal updrafts and rapid thunderstorm development over the crest, turning the unprotected basin into a hazardous lightning zone. Wind is an almost constant factor, ripping down from the high passes and chilling surface temperatures quickly. Pack warm layers and bombproof tent anchors even during warm midsummer stretches in the lowlands.
Wildlife and Fishery Dynamics
Beyond marmots, pikas, and the occasional raptor riding ridgeline thermals, the primary biological draw here is underwater. The lake supports a self-sustaining population of pure-strain or near-pure golden trout that run notably thicker and longer than average Sierra specimens. Due to the rapid depth drop, large fish cruise the narrow littoral shelf to forage on midges, caddis pupae, and terrestrial windfalls before retreating to the security of the deep turquoise trench. Anglers must crawl across exposed boulders and cast 12-foot leaders tapered to 6x fluorocarbon to avoid spooking these wary fish. Terrestrial patterns, zebra midges, and small scud imitations consistently produce the best takes.
Access and Navigation
The standard approach begins at the Pine Creek Trailhead on the eastern slope, ascending roughly 4,000 feet of unrelenting switchbacks past old tungsten mining relics to cross Pine Creek Pass. From near the pass crest, you leave established tread behind to navigate off-trail ramps and steep talus slopes into the hanging Royce basin. An alternate route approaches from the west via Piute Pass, French Canyon, and a grueling, trackless climb alongside the Royce outflow creek. Both options require solid class 2 boulder navigation, accurate map-and-compass skills, and sturdy footwear capable of gripping loose scree while hauling a multi-day pack.
Permits and Land Management
The lake sits within the John Muir Wilderness inside Sierra National Forest, but most visitors start on the Inyo National Forest side via Pine Creek. Quota permits are mandatory for overnight stays between May and November through Recreation.gov. Bear canisters are strictly required throughout this corridor, and packing them properly is non-negotiable since food hangs are impossible above treeline. Campfire bans are absolute at this elevation, so a dependable canister stove is mandatory. Given the extreme lack of soil, low-impact waste disposal requires strict adherence to pack-out policies or careful locating of deep sand pockets well back from the lake.
Hazards and Honest Realities
This is not a casual destination. Finding a level, unyielding tent site among the jagged granite slabs requires patience, and guyout points usually rely on heavy rocks rather than stakes. Altitude sickness is a real threat given the rapid elevation gain directly from the Owens Valley floor; spending a night acclimating before ascending Pine Creek Pass is strongly advised. Footing on the cross-country sections involves shifted boulders and unstable talus where an ankle injury means a complicated backcountry rescue. Finally, the winds here can be ferocious enough to flatten lightweight three-season shelters without warning.
How we chose
We built this ranking from land-manager and agency sources, permit records and published trip reports. Each of the 10 places was compared against the same criteria below. This is desk research unless a pick is marked field tested.
- Quality of the terrain
- Landscape, route variety, and whether the place rewards multiple days rather than one overlook.
- Season and weather windows
- How long the reliable window is, and how badly the shoulder seasons punish a bad forecast.
- Access and permits
- Trailhead logistics, permit odds, quotas, and how much lead time a trip realistically takes.
- Solitude vs. crowding
- How far you have to walk before the place feels like wilderness instead of a queue.
- Wildlife and ecology
- What you can reasonably expect to see, and what you have to plan around.
- Risk and skill required
- Navigation, water crossings, exposure, and rescue distance — stated plainly.
Royce Lake #2 — frequently asked questions
- Is Royce Lake #2 worth the trip?
- We rank it #4 in Sierra Golden Trout Lakes. The Royce Lakes Basin sits suspended above French Canyon at roughly 11,700 feet, a stark, windswept granite plateau containing five distinct lakes. Royce Lake #2 is the crown jewel of the basin, featuring profound water depth, sheer talus borders, and a self-sustaining population of golden trout that regularly…
- Who is Royce Lake #2 best for?
- Best for stalking trophy backcountry goldens, advanced cross-country alpine backpacking, high-elevation photography and scrambling and multi-day high sierra fly fishing circuits. Standouts: supports significantly larger golden trout than surrounding high-altitude waters and spectacular high-alpine amphitheater with stunning turquoise water clarity.
- What are the drawbacks of Royce Lake #2?
- Exhausting approach with more than 4,000 vertical feet of climbing, Virtually no shelter from howling winds, hail, and high-altitude lightning and Extremely limited flat ground for setting up tents without rock interference.
- What are the key details for Royce Lake #2?
- Elevation: Approximately 11,740 feet · Managing Agency: Sierra National Forest / Inyo National Forest · Primary Trailhead: Pine Creek Pack Station (Rounds Valley) · Round-Trip Distance: Roughly 18 to 22 miles depending on route · Target Species: California golden trout (Oncorhynchus aguabonita)
- Terrain and Hydrology — what should I know about the Royce Lake #2?
- Royce Lake #2 rests in an alpine hanging valley hollowed out by glacial action, bound by massive talus aprons and polished granodiorite slabs. The lake water owes its brilliant blue-green color to extreme clarity, depth, and trace glacial silt carried down from late-melting snowfields beneath the ridgelines.
- Weather Windows and Timing — what should I know about the Royce Lake #2?
- Snow hangs on tenaciously in the Royce Basin well into summer. Ice-out rarely completes before early July, and in heavy snow years, solid slush and drifting bergs can linger into August.
Compare side by side
Put the Royce Lake #2 against any other pick on this list — specs, price, pros, cons and reader ratings.


