Skip to content
Wild10

Become a contributor

Join

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Top 10 Wind River Trout Lakes head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Shadow Lake

#7 on this list

Shadow Lake

Bridger Wilderness, Wyoming

Shadow Lake sits at 10,150 feet tucked tightly against the western backside of the Cirque of the Towers, framed by the soaring buttress of Overhanging Tower. The water is deep and clean, holding a self-sustaining mix of cutthroat trout and golden hybrids that feed near the outlet and along the steep northern talus banks. The approach covers about 11 miles from Big Sandy Trailhead via the Fremont Trail and Shadow Lake Trail. The gradient is gentler than the haul over Jackass Pass, making it an excellent base camp for anglers wanting alpine fishing without the intense crowds of the eastern Cirque. August brings peak terrestrial action, with winds depositing grasshoppers and flying ants from the lower meadows onto the water's surface. Early morning offers glass-smooth water and cruising fish right at the edge of the granite shelves. A standard 9-foot 4-weight rod with 5X or 6X fluorocarbon tippet is ideal for sight-casting here. **Highlights** * Elevation: 10,150 feet * Target species: Cutthroat trout, golden hybrids * Approach: 11 miles one-way from Big Sandy * Staggering vertical views of the Cirque’s back-wall spires * Outstanding sight-fishing along the eastern inlet flats **Watch-outs** * Heavy horse-packer use on the lower approach trails creates deep mud * Camping spots on dry, flat ground are limited and rocky * Early July visits will contend with fierce mosquito swarms

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Island Lake

#8 on this list

Island Lake

Bridger Wilderness, Wyoming

Island Lake is the undisputed crossroads of the central Bridger Wilderness, situated at 10,380 feet. Characterized by its granite islets and deeply indented shoreline, the lake sits right at the edge of the subalpine and alpine zones, offering both cutthroat trout and lingering populations of brookies and goldens. Located 12 miles from Elkhart Park outside Pinedale, Island Lake serves as the staging ground for pushes into Titcomb and Indian Basins. While it sees substantial wilderness camping traffic, the sheer size of the lake and its numerous bays mean an angler willing to hike off the trail can easily find quiet water. The optimal window spans from late July through the end of August. The fishing is varied. Shallow weed beds in the warmer western coves support healthy invertebrate life, while the drop-offs around the central islands hold larger, predatory cruisers. Stripping woolly buggers or leeches on an intermediate line during overcast afternoons often provokes the lake's better fish. **Highlights** * Elevation: 10,380 feet * Target species: Cutthroat trout, golden trout, brook trout * Mileage: 12 miles one-way from Elkhart Park * Extensive shoreline with multiple bays, shelves, and granite points * Reliable base camp infrastructure with good water sources **Watch-outs** * High human density and heavily impacted designated campsites * Strict wilderness food-storage regulations enforced by USFS rangers * Extended trek through the burn zone near the trailhead on hot days

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Shadow Lake versus Island Lake specifications
SpecShadow LakeIsland Lake
Elevation10,150 feet—
Approach Distance11 miles one-way12 miles one-way
Fish SpeciesCutthroat trout, golden trout hybrids—
TrailheadBig Sandy TrailheadElkhart Park
Management AgencyBridger-Teton National Forest—
Optimal SeasonLate July through early September—
Surface Elevation—10,380 feet
Target Species—Cutthroat trout, brook trout
Managing Agency—Bridger-Teton National Forest
Prime Window—Late July through August

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Shadow Lake

  • World-class sight-fishing for vibrant cutthroat and hybrid trout in gin-clear water
  • Substantially less crowded than the popular eastern Cirque of the Towers camping zones
  • Gradual, moderate elevation gain compared to brutal passes like Jackass or Texas
  • Dramatic backdrop beneath towering granite spires and western cirque walls
  • Limited flat, durable campsite options meeting wilderness setback regulations
  • Heavily churned, muddy approach trails caused by frequent horse-packer traffic
  • Fierce mosquito swarms that plague the basin through mid-July

Island Lake

  • Diverse underwater structure with points, weed beds, and island drop-offs
  • Superb base camp for quick morning pushes into Titcomb and Indian Basins
  • Reliable cutthroat and brook trout action on both dries and streamers
  • Well-engineered approach trail with abundant water access en route
  • High campsite density and significant human presence around the trail
  • Strict two-hundred-foot lakeshore setback limits good tent sites
  • Punishing mosquito populations through early and mid-July

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.