Skip to content
Wild10

Become a contributor

Join

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Top 10 Wind River Trout Lakes head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Upper Titcomb Lake

#1 on this list

Upper Titcomb Lake

Bridger Wilderness, Wyoming

Perched at 10,580 feet in the glacial trench beneath Fremont and Jackson Peaks, Upper Titcomb Lake is the crown jewel of high-altitude angling in the Winds. The water here is cold, mineral-lean, and turquoise from granite flour. Despite the sterile appearance, healthy populations of golden-cutthroat hybrids and pure golden trout cruise the rocky drop-offs, foraging along underwater scree slopes. Access requires a committed 15-mile trek from the Elkhart Park Trailhead near Pinedale, following the Pole Creek and Seneca Lake trails past Island Lake before entering the basin proper. Late July through August is the sole viable window; ice can lock the outlet well into July, and winter conditions regularly arrive by Labor Day. Camping is prohibited within 200 feet of the water to protect the fragile alpine tundra, so most anglers base camp at the lower basin or Island Lake and day-hike the upper shelf with light fly tackle. Fish here are opportunistic yet cautious. Because the growing season is minuscule, they will inspect black gnats, Griffith's Gnats, and small scuds, but any sloppy casting or heavy footfall sends them bolting into the deep cobalt center. **Highlights** * Elevation: 10,580 feet * Target species: Golden trout, golden-cutthroat hybrids * Mileage: Roughly 30 to 32 miles round-trip via Elkhart Park * Dramatic setting directly under 13,000-foot peaks * Abundant sight-casting along shallow granite shelves **Watch-outs** * Completely exposed with zero tree cover or storm shelter * Camping bans within 200 feet of lakes and streams throughout the basin * Heavy summer hiker traffic along the main approach trail

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Upper Cook Lake

#2 on this list

Upper Cook Lake

Bridger Wilderness, Wyoming

Upper Cook Lake sits at 10,200 feet in an expansive granite amphitheater that historically served as one of the critical broodstocks for California golden trout in Wyoming. While lower Cook Lake sees more camping pressure, Upper Cook requires navigating unmaintained spur trails and boulder hopping around the narrows, which weeds out casual backpackers and preserves an exceptional wilderness fishery. Reaching the lake requires roughly 18 miles from Elkhart Park via the Highline and Pole Creek trails. Pinedale is the jumping-off point for provisions and bear canisters, which are strongly recommended across the western slope. Mid-August is optimal, when water temperatures peak and subsurface insect activity triggers surface rises near the inlet streams tumbling down from the Continental Divide. Anglers will find goldens here with deep crimson bellies and vibrant par marks. A sinking-tip line or weighted nymph rig is useful when afternoon winds chop the surface, but early mornings often offer glass-calm sight-fishing with ant patterns and elk hair caddis. **Highlights** * Elevation: 10,215 feet * Target species: Pure-strain and hybridized golden trout * Approach: 18 miles one-way from Elkhart Park Trailhead * Excellent sight-casting over submerged glacial moraines * Historic connection to early Wyoming golden trout propagation **Watch-outs** * Sustained mosquito hatches through late July * Difficult boulder-field navigation to circle the upper shoreline * Afternoon thunderstorms generate violent lightning along the open plateau

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Upper Titcomb Lake versus Upper Cook Lake specifications
SpecUpper Titcomb LakeUpper Cook Lake
Elevation10,580 feet10,215 feet
LocationBridger Wilderness, Wyoming—
Route Distance30 to 32 miles round-trip—
Target SpeciesGolden trout, golden-cutthroat hybrids—
Primary TrailheadElkhart Park Trailhead near Pinedale—
Land ManagerUSFS / Bridger-Teton National Forest—
Trailhead—Elkhart Park (Pinedale, WY)
Approach Distance—18 miles one-way
Primary Target—Golden trout
Governing Agency—Bridger-Teton National Forest
Wilderness Status—Bridger Wilderness

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Upper Titcomb Lake

  • World-class alpine scenery surrounded by sheer 13,000-foot granite summits
  • Genuine opportunity to sight-fish for wild golden trout and hybrids
  • Pristine water clarity ideal for stalking fish along submerged drop-offs
  • Expansive shoreline access with endless underwater shelves and boulder structure
  • Zero tree cover leaves anglers completely exposed to sudden mountain lightning
  • Heavily traveled approach corridor with dense trail crowds around Island Lake
  • Short open-water window often limited to six weeks between thaws

Upper Cook Lake

  • World-class sight-fishing for vibrant high-altitude golden trout
  • Significantly less camping pressure and noise than Lower Cook Lake
  • Stunning alpine setting enclosed by sheer Continental Divide granite
  • Unregulated wilderness permits allow flexible summer trip planning
  • Grueling 18-mile one-way approach demands high backcountry fitness
  • Extreme exposure to violent afternoon lightning above timberline
  • Difficult off-trail boulder scrambling required along the shoreline

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.