Reader rating
Rate it and you move it. Community ratings re-rank this product inside its Top 10 list.
Expert-picked, reader-ranked. Our editors choose the products and the launch order; member star ratings move picks up or down over time.
Knoll Golf Club West is designed for architecture purists who love Golden Age template holes and vintage course character. Located in Boonton, New Jersey, and owned by the Township of Parsippany-Troy Hills, this 1929 gem was designed by Charles Banks, a disciple of Charles Blair Macdonald and Seth Raynor. Known as 'Steam Shovel' Banks for his bold earthmoving techniques, he packed this public layout with legendary template features. The course showcases classic architecture staples, including a stunning Biarritz green with a deep mid-surface swale, a dramatic Redan par three, and an Eden hole defended by deep, steep-faced bunkers. The routing moves gracefully across rolling hills, bringing significant elevation shifts into play on both drives and approaches. Because the green complexes sit elevated with deep sand pits guarding the fronts and sides, running the ball onto the putting surfaces is rarely an option; you must fly it to the green. The trade-offs here stem from its age and heavy public foot traffic. While the bones of the architecture are world-class, municipal maintenance budgets occasionally mean uneven bunker sand consistency or slower green speeds compared to modern luxury public courses. Even so, playing an authentic Charles Banks template course for public rates is one of the northeast's great architectural bargains. **Highlights** - Classic 1929 Golden Age design by Charles 'Steam Shovel' Banks - Authentic template holes including a dramatic Biarritz, Redan, and Eden - Massive, steep-faced bunker complexes that penalize miss-hit approaches - Rolling hillside topography creating memorable, elevated tee shots - Accessible green fees that deliver outstanding historical architectural value **Watch-outs** - Turf and bunker conditions can show wear during peak summer municipal traffic - Elevated, well-guarded greens require forced aerial carries into par threes
Pros
- Rare, accessible public design by Golden Age architect Charles Banks
- Authentic template holes including an expansive Biarritz and dramatic Redan
- Rolling topography delivers natural elevation changes and strategic tee shots
- Sub-$100 rate offers standout architectural value in the Northeast
Cons
- Elevated greens and deep bunkers severely penalize low-trajectory hitters
- Bunker sand consistency and turf density fluctuate under municipal maintenance
- Pace of play can slow down significantly during peak weekend tee sheets
Best uses
- Historic Golf Architecture Study
- Public Strategic Golf Outings
- Aerial Iron Play Practice
- Value Focused Weekend Rounds
Specifications
- Architect
- Charles Banks
- Year Opened
- 1929
- Location
- Boonton, New Jersey
- Ownership
- Township of Parsippany-Troy Hills
- Estimated Green Fee
- Around $90
- Design Style
- Golden Age Template
Pricing
We don't publish a price we haven't verified. The retailer links below open the live listing for this exact model.
Best for
Historic Golf Architecture Study, Public Strategic Golf Outings, Aerial Iron Play Practice, Value Focused Weekend Rounds
Where to buy the Golf Club (West)
We don't have a direct Amazon listing on file yet — this opens an Amazon search for the exact make and model.
Some links are affiliate links. Buying through them supports our testing at no extra cost to you.
Knoll Golf Club West occupies a rare niche in American municipal golf. Located in Boonton, New Jersey, and operated by the Township of Parsippany-Troy Hills, this 1929 layout preserves the strategic tenets of Golden Age golf architecture at an accessible public price point. Designed by Charles Banks, a prominent disciple of Seth Raynor and Charles Blair Macdonald, the course delivers classic template designs that are almost exclusively found at high-end private clubs throughout the northeastern United States. Banks earned the moniker Steam Shovel for his aggressive earthmoving, which is on full display across Knoll West's rolling hills. The routing utilizes the site's natural elevation changes to frame approaches into elevated green complexes heavily defended by massive, deep-set bunkers. Golfers encounter authentic iterations of historic template holes, including an imposing Biarritz complete with its signature mid-green trench, alongside sharp Redan and Eden complexes. Because it operates as a municipal facility handling significant regional traffic, Knoll West does not exhibit the pristine conditioning of private Golden Age estates. Players will observe regular wear in high-traffic zones and variable bunker consistency. Nonetheless, the integrity of Banks's strategic design remains intact, offering architecture purists and public golfers a formidable tactical test for around $90.
Golden Age Architectural Lineage
Knoll West stands out primarily because of its pedigree. Charles Banks worked closely with Seth Raynor and Charles Blair Macdonald, absorbing their philosophies on classic European golf architecture. When Banks laid out Knoll West in 1929, he translated those historic principles onto a public canvas. Known for using heavy industrial steam shovels to craft towering mounds and sunken hazards, Banks imparted scale and drama to the landscape. Unlike modern municipal layouts that often rely on artificial ponds or generic mounding, Knoll West presents clear strategic corridors dictated by geometric hazards, tiered greens, and distinct strategic angles that require golfers to think several shots ahead.
Historic Template Hole Execution
The primary draw for discerning golfers is the collection of template holes integrated into the routing. Knoll West features a classic Biarritz green, defined by a deep swale bisecting the putting surface that demands precise trajectory control to reach back pin locations. The Redan hole requires players to land their tee shot on an angled slope to feed the ball toward a well-guarded target, while the Eden hole incorporates steep-faced front bunkers designed to penalize short misses. These holes are not merely decorative tributes; they retain the severe slopes and demanding shot values conceived nearly a century ago, testing distance control and short-game touch.
Terrain and Shot Demands
The course routes across rugged northern New Jersey hillside topography, producing substantial elevation shifts from tee to green. Approaches often play uphill or across pronounced valleys, making yardage calculation tricky in variable wind. Because Banks elevated putting complexes above grade and ringed them with cavernous bunkers, ground-game options are severely restricted. Golfers cannot easily bounce approaches onto the putting surfaces; the course demands high, soft-landing iron shots that clear fronting hazards. Misses above the hole leave treacherous downhill putts across greens that feature pronounced interior contouring.
Municipal Upkeep and Conditioning
Managing expectations regarding turf conditions is necessary when visiting Knoll West. As a public facility operating on a municipal maintenance budget, it endures steady foot traffic throughout the peak Northeast golf season. Fairways and tee boxes occasionally show divot wear and seasonal stress during hot summer stretches. Bunker sand depth and firmness can also fluctuate across the property, creating inconsistent lies in deep green-side pits. While the putting surfaces generally roll true, they are typically kept at moderate speeds to prevent public rounds from stalling on the severe slopes.
Public Value and Positioning
At an approximate $90 rate, Knoll West represents exceptional architectural value in a region where private Golden Age clubs command substantial membership fees. It competes favorably against public daily-fee facilities that often charge double for modern, less characterful layouts. While players sacrifice the manicured perfection, upscale clubhouse amenities, and rapid pace of play found at premier daily-fee resorts, the opportunity to study and play an unadulterated Charles Banks layout makes it an essential stop for public players seeking historic substance over surface polish.
Strategic Advice and Playability
Succeeding at Knoll West requires disciplined target selection rather than raw power off the tee. Finding the correct tier on Banks's expansive greens is critical to avoiding three-putt situations, meaning players must often favor safe landing zones over aggressive flag-hunting. High-handicap golfers who struggle with forced aerial carries may find the steep bunker faces and elevated approaches frustrating. Packing extra wedges, prioritizing center-of-the-green approach targets, and accepting conservative bogeys when out of position will prevent big numbers on this demanding layout.
How we picked
We started with a long list of america’s 20 best municipal golf courses that people actually buy, cut anything that could not clear our baseline for durability and field performance, then ranked the 10 that were left against the same criteria. Rankings are editorial. No brand pays for placement, and affiliate links never move a pick up or down.
- Real-world durability
- How the material, stitching, or steel holds up after a season of hard use — not how it looks new.
- Performance in bad conditions
- Wind, rain, cold, and grit are the test. Anything that only works on a nice day gets marked down.
- Weight and packability
- Every ounce has to earn its place in the pack, but not at the cost of something that fails in the field.
- Ease of use
- Setup, adjustment, and maintenance with cold hands, in the dark, without the manual.
- Value at its price point
- Compared against the closest competitors in the same tier, not against cheaper gear in a different class.
- Repairability and support
- Field-fixable design, available parts, and a warranty the maker actually honors.
Golf Club (West) — frequently asked questions
- Is the Golf Club (West) worth it?
- We rank it #9 in America’S 20 Best Municipal Golf Courses. Knoll Golf Club West is designed for architecture purists who love Golden Age template holes and vintage course character. Located in Boonton, New Jersey, and owned by the Township of Parsippany-Troy Hills, this 1929 gem was designed by Charles Banks, a disciple of Charles Blair Macdonald and Seth Raynor.
- What is the Golf Club (West) best for?
- Best for historic golf architecture study, public strategic golf outings, aerial iron play practice and value focused weekend rounds. Standouts: rare, accessible public design by golden age architect charles banks and authentic template holes including an expansive biarritz and dramatic redan.
- What are the downsides of the Golf Club (West)?
- Elevated greens and deep bunkers severely penalize low-trajectory hitters, Bunker sand consistency and turf density fluctuate under municipal maintenance and Pace of play can slow down significantly during peak weekend tee sheets.
- What are the key specs of the Golf Club (West)?
- Architect: Charles Banks · Year Opened: 1929 · Location: Boonton, New Jersey · Ownership: Township of Parsippany-Troy Hills · Estimated Green Fee: Around $90
- Golden Age Architectural Lineage — what should I know about the Golf Club (West)?
- Knoll West stands out primarily because of its pedigree. Charles Banks worked closely with Seth Raynor and Charles Blair Macdonald, absorbing their philosophies on classic European golf architecture.
- Historic Template Hole Execution — what should I know about the Golf Club (West)?
- The primary draw for discerning golfers is the collection of template holes integrated into the routing. Knoll West features a classic Biarritz green, defined by a deep swale bisecting the putting surface that demands precise trajectory control to reach back pin locations.
Compare side by side
Put the Golf Club (West) against any other pick on this list — specs, price, pros, cons and reader ratings.