Best of the Best: Power Clucker PC-1 vs Super Mag
Power Clucker PC-1 vs Super Mag
Our #1 and #2 picks from The 10 Best Goose Calls, compared spec-by-spec with clear pros, cons, and a verdict.
Choosing the right goose call can significantly impact your success in the field, turning a good hunt into a great one. Today, we're pitting two legendary short-reed goose calls against each other: the Zink Power Clucker PC-1 and the Tim Grounds Super Mag. Both are renowned for their ability to bring wary geese into gun range, but they cater to slightly different calling styles and preferences. Whether you're a seasoned caller looking for a new edge or a dedicated beginner ready to invest in a top-tier instrument, understanding the nuances between these two powerhouses is crucial. We'll break down their features, performance, and ideal users to help you make an informed decision and ensure your next call purchase perfectly matches your hunting strategy and personal calling style.
Power Clucker PC-1
Zink
The reference short reed: crisp breaks, deep moans, and enough air to hail across a section.
Find it on AmazonSuper Mag
Tim Grounds
A legendary short reed with a deep, growly tone that finishes wary Canadas.
Find it on AmazonSpec-by-Spec
| Spec | #1 Power Clucker PC-1 | #2 Super Mag |
|---|---|---|
| Call Type | Short-Reed Goose Call | Short-Reed Goose Call |
| Weight | Light | Medium |
| Capacity/Sound Profile | Raspy, deep goosey notes, aggressive clucks | Loud, deep, powerful low-end, realistic honks |
| Materials | Acrylic | Acrylic |
| Price Tier | Premium | Premium |
| Warranty | Not published (typically limited lifetime) | Not published (typically limited lifetime) |
| Best Use | Aggressive calling, open fields, competition | Long-range calling, windy conditions, big honkers |
| Portability | Compact, fits in lanyard | Compact, fits in lanyard |
| Durability | Excellent (acrylic) | Excellent (acrylic) |
| Feature Highlights | LAS (Lip Alignment System), easy to get raspy low end | Specifically designed for maximum volume and deep tone |
Power Clucker PC-1
Best for: Hunters who want a versatile, raspy call for aggressive close-to-mid range calling and competition.
Pros
- Known for its exceptionally raspy, deep goose sounds
- Relatively easy to operate for a high-performance call
- Excellent for creating aggressive, realistic clucks and honks
- Versatile for field and competition use
Cons
- May require some practice for full mastery of its range
- Slightly less overall volume than the Super Mag
- Can be sensitive to moisture if not maintained
Super Mag
Best for: Hunters needing maximum volume and deep, booming honks to pull in geese from extreme distances, especially in open, windy areas.
Pros
- Unmatched volume, cuts through wind effectively
- Produces incredibly deep, guttural honks for big geese
- Favored by many champion callers for its power
- Excellent for long-range calling scenarios
Cons
- Requires significant air pressure and good air control
- Can be a bit more challenging for beginners to master
- Higher volume can be overpowering in close-quarters hunting
The Verdict
For dedicated goose hunters seeking a top-tier instrument, both the Zink Power Clucker PC-1 and the Tim Grounds Super Mag deliver exceptional performance. The **Tim Grounds Super Mag** takes a slight edge as the overall winner for its sheer power and ability to reach out to distant birds, making it a staple for hunting wide-open spaces or in windy conditions. However, the Zink PC-1 is a formidable contender, especially for callers who prioritize a rich, raspy tone and aggressive calling sequences. While the Super Mag demands more air and technique, its reward is unparalleled volume and deep honks that simply command attention. The PC-1 offers a slightly more forgiving learning curve for its complex sounds, making it a fantastic choice for those developing advanced calling skills. Ultimately, your choice hinges on your primary hunting environment and calling style.