The full head-to-head write-up is generating and will appear here shortly. In the meantime, here's the editorial summary for each pick from the Top 10.

#1

Lone Peak 9

Altra

The thru-hiker default: wide toe box, zero drop, and a footshape that prevents late-day swelling pain.

#2

Speedgoat 6

Hoka

Vibram Megagrip with maximal cushion. The best long-mile shoe for rocky trail.