Skip to content

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Ultralight Pyramid Backpacking Tarps head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Cinder Cone 4P

#7 on this list

Cinder Cone 4P

SlingFin

The SlingFin Cinder Cone 4P is a specialized four-person pyramid shelter engineered for high-altitude expeditions, winter ski traverses, and group fastpacking missions. Coming from a brand renowned for high-wind stability, the Cinder Cone leverages advanced fabric technology and rigorous structural design to create an alpine group shelter that withstands conditions that would tear lesser tarps apart. The shelter is built with high-tenacity nylon fabrics featuring advanced silicone coatings that resist UV degradation and maintain tear strength over years of hard use. Its massive internal footprint can sleep four mountaineers in a pinch or provide a commodious basecamp living and cooking area for two to three people during severe storms. The peak accommodates ski poles or central struts with heavily reinforced rigging. Because of its large surface area, pitching the Cinder Cone requires solid anchoring skills and significant clearance, making it less practical for narrow, heavily forested campsites. It is primarily built for open alpine terrain, snowfields, and wide-open ridges where its wind-shearing shape can perform as designed. **Highlights** - Expedition-grade wind and snow load resistance for up to four people - Premium silicone-coated fabrics maximize UV resistance and tear strength - Massive internal volume functions as a sleeping shelter or group basecamp mess - Reinforced apex accommodates paired ski poles or heavy-duty center poles - Plentiful perimeter tie-outs provide exceptional anchoring security **Watch-outs** - Broad perimeter footprint requires significant open space to pitch properly - Sized beyond the needs of solo or standard two-person hiking teams

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Front Range

#8 on this list

Front Range

MSR

The MSR Front Range is an ultra-versatile, four-person floorless pyramid shelter designed to bridge the gap between lightweight mountaineering and four-season backcountry travel. Highly capable as a spring ski traverse shelter or an alpine basecamp, the Front Range offers a classic square mid profile that pitches quickly using ski poles, trekking poles, or a dedicated accessory pole. Constructed from MSR’s durable Xtreme Shield-coated polyester, the Front Range resists fabric sag when wet and provides robust water repellency over prolonged use. The steep roofline sheds heavy snow accumulations with ease, while the zippered door features an integrated peak vent to encourage airflow and minimize condensation buildup. At its size, it provides an exceptional ratio of sheltered square footage to packed weight. While it can sleep four adults tightly, it functions most comfortably as a luxury shelter for two or three with extensive alpine gear. Like all large mids, pitching in heavy winds requires securing all corners firmly before erecting the center pole, and it lacks an integrated floor unless paired with MSR’s modular inner insert. **Highlights** - Spacious four-person interior with exceptional vertical ceiling clearance - Xtreme Shield coating resists long-term fabric breakdown and morning sag - Steep pyramid architecture easily sheds blowing snow and torrential rain - Packable design rolls down surprisingly small for a four-person alpine canopy - Steeper wall angles optimize usable edge space for cots or thick pads **Watch-outs** - Massive footprint can be challenging to pitch in cramped forest sites - Inner bug and floor shelter must be purchased separately for summer use

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Cinder Cone 4P versus Front Range specifications
SpecCinder Cone 4PFront Range
Shelter TypeUltralight 4-person pyramid tarp—
Primary MaterialHigh-tenacity silicone-coated nylon—
Support RequirementAdjustable center pole or paired ski poles—
Capacity3 to 4 adults plus gear4 person
Season Rating4-season / alpine expedition—
Entry StyleSingle zippered storm entry—
Canopy Fabric—30D ripstop polyester
Waterproof Coating—1500mm Xtreme Shield PU & silicone
Minimum Weight—1 lb 10 oz (740 g)
Floor Area—81 sq ft (7.52 sq m)
Peak Height—64 in (162 cm)

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Cinder Cone 4P

  • Superior tear strength and UV durability from pure silicone-coated nylon
  • Generous interior volume fits four sleepers or acts as a winter basecamp mess
  • Proven wind and snow-shedding geometry for high-altitude environments
  • Reinforced apex handles paired ski poles or dedicated mid struts easily
  • Massive perimeter footprint requires wide, clear campsites
  • Too large and heavy for solo or casual two-person three-season hiking
  • Single-wall floorless design requires careful condensation management

Front Range

  • Polyester fabric resists stretching and sagging when saturated with rain or snow
  • Extremely spacious for two to three occupants with winter expedition gear
  • Pitches easily with strapped ski poles or trekking poles without specialized hardware
  • Steep pyramid walls shed snow loads and high alpine winds reliably
  • Massive footprint requires large, flat clearings that are scarce in dense forests
  • Floorless configuration requires separate accessory mesh insert for bug protection
  • Four-person rating is tight with thick winter sleeping pads and personal gear

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.