Skip to content
Wild10

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Best Windbreakers head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Back to the full Top 10
Alpine Start Hoody

#5 on this list

Alpine Start Hoody

Black Diamond

Schoeller stretch woven that hikes like a softshell and blocks wind like a shell.

Price
USD 185.00
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Vital Windshell Hoody

#6 on this list

Vital Windshell Hoody

Rab

Pertex Quantum Air with a fitted hood. The best value technical wind layer.

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Alpine Start Hoody versus Vital Windshell Hoody specifications
SpecAlpine Start HoodyVital Windshell Hoody
MakerBlack Diamond
ModelAlpine Start Hoody
FabricSchoeller stretch-woven
FitSlim, athleticRegular
HoodHelmet-compatibleFitted, elasticated
Weight classUltralight softshell/windbreaker
MaterialPertex Quantum Air
WeightApprox. 130g (men's M)
PackabilityStuffs into own pocket
Pockets1 chest pocket (stuffsack)

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Alpine Start Hoody

  • Exceptional breathability for a wind layer
  • Excellent four-way stretch for unrestricted movement
  • Packs down incredibly small into its own pocket
  • Impressive wind resistance for its weight
  • Durable Schoeller fabric holds up well to abuse
  • Not fully waterproof; offers only light water resistance
  • Slim fit might not suit all body types or layering preferences
  • Higher price point than basic wind shells

Vital Windshell Hoody

  • Excellent wind resistance for its weight
  • Highly breathable Pertex Quantum Air fabric
  • Outstanding value for money
  • Extremely lightweight and packable
  • Well-designed, functional hood
  • Minimal features (no hand pockets)
  • Limited water resistance (not for heavy rain)
  • Can feel a bit thin in very cold, still conditions

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.