Skip to content

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Winter Gloves and Mittens head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Fission SV

#10 on this list

Fission SV

Arc'teryx

The Arc'teryx Fission SV is a premium, technical ski and alpine glove designed for severe, wet-cold mountain environments. OutdoorGearLab recognized it as a premier glove for winter sports, reflecting its refined balance of weatherproof reliability, anatomical patterning, and moderate warmth. It is aimed at skiers, snowboarders, and mountaineers who frequently encounter wet Pacific storms, heavy mixed precipitation, or freezing temperatures where staying dry is critical. Construction begins with an external softshell fabric backed by a guaranteed waterproof Gore-Tex insert that stops driving snow and slush in its tracks. The palm and fingers are wrapped in durable, supple leather that provides dependable grip on ski poles while resisting abrasions from metal edges. Arc'teryx applies a mapped synthetic insulation package designed to deliver warmth without ballooning the glove's profile. The gauntlet cuff is designed to slide smoothly over jacket sleeves, cinching down tight with an easy pull tab. Arc'teryx's legendary attention to patterning gives the Fission SV noticeably better dexterity than many gloves with comparable weatherproofing. However, that performance comes with a steep price tag near $200. In addition, while the 'SV' designation denotes severe weather capability, those who run notoriously cold may find the streamlined insulation slightly lean on exceptionally bitter, sub-zero chairlift rides compared to bulkier expedition alternatives. **Highlights** - Gore-Tex waterproof insert keeps hands dry in the wettest, heaviest snowfalls - Premium leather palm and fingers provide exceptional grip and long-term durability - Articulated patterning offers superior dexterity compared to bulky heavy-duty gloves - Gauntlet cuff with glove-friendly drawcord closures seals cleanly over jacket sleeves - Soft interior lining wicks internal moisture away from fingers during active descents **Watch-outs** - Very high price point represents a significant investment for a winter glove - Streamlined insulation may feel inadequate for people who suffer from chronically cold hands - Leather requires occasional treatment to maintain water repellency over seasons

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Guide

#1 on this list

Guide

Black Diamond

The Black Diamond Guide sits at the top of the category as an uncompromising cold-weather workhorse. Built primarily for dedicated resort skiers, mountain guides, and backcountry professionals, this glove targets severe weather where sub-par insulation and moisture seepage are unacceptable risks. Independent testers routinely praise its high thermal retention, noting that it manages harsh alpine conditions and heavy snow better than almost any conventional five-finger model on the market. Its durability stems from a burly build featuring woven nylon backed by thick goat leather across the palm and high-wear zones. Rather than relying on a delicate, paper-thin membrane, the Guide uses a dedicated waterproof insert paired with a removable liner system packed with heavy-duty insulation. The removable liner makes drying out overnight straightforward, which is critical during multi-day ski trips or hut tours. Foam padding over the knuckles adds welcome impact defense when busting through trees or working with metal gear in freezing weather. The trade-off for this bombproof construction is weight and bulk. At roughly 11 ounces, the Guide is a heavy, stiff glove out of the box, requiring a break-in period before the leather softens. Dexterity is inevitably modest; you will easily grip ski poles or shovel handles, but manipulating smaller zippers, phone screens, or boot buckles usually requires pulling them off. **Highlights** - Removable insulated liner accelerates drying times on multi-day winter trips - Durable goat leather palm and knuckle patches resist intense rope and ski edge abrasion - Fully waterproof insert keeps wet snow and slush out during foul-weather storms - Deep gauntlet cuff seals out powder and slides easily over bulky jacket sleeves - Molded EVA foam padding protects knuckles from hard impacts and scrapes **Watch-outs** - Thick insulation and heavy materials significantly limit fine motor dexterity - Stiff out of the box and requires substantial break-in time to soften - High price point makes it an overbuilt investment for casual, around-town winter wear

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Fission SV versus Guide specifications
SpecFission SVGuide
MSRPAround $200—
MembraneGore-Tex waterproof insert—
Palm MaterialTreated leather reinforcement—
Cuff StyleExtended gauntlet with drawcordExtended gauntlet with drawcord
InsulationMapped synthetic fill—
Primary UseDownhill skiing and alpine sports—
Retail Price—Around $190
Total Weight—Approximately 11 oz
Shell Materials—Woven nylon and goat leather
Liner Design—Removable insulated liner
Waterproofing—Fully waterproof insert

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Fission SV

  • Refined anatomical patterning yields exceptional dexterity for a winter glove
  • Gore-Tex insert provides dependable defense against wet snow and slush
  • Leather palm reinforcement provides positive grip and edge abrasion resistance
  • Gauntlet cuff cinches smoothly over bulky hardshell jacket sleeves
  • High price tag represents a significant investment for a winter glove
  • Streamlined insulation runs cool during bitter, static sub-zero conditions
  • Integrated lining takes longer to dry thoroughly than modular liner gloves

Guide

  • Exceptional thermal retention in sub-zero alpine conditions
  • Heavy-duty goat leather exterior resists severe abrasion
  • Removable insulated liner significantly accelerates drying times
  • Wide gauntlet cuff easily seals over thick jacket sleeves
  • Substantial bulk limits fine motor dexterity and pocket access
  • Stiff leather requires an extended break-in period
  • Overly warm for mild weather or high-output aerobic ascents

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.