Skip to content

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Winter Gloves and Mittens head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Sureshot Pro - Men's

#5 on this list

Sureshot Pro - Men's

Outdoor Research

The Outdoor Research Sureshot Pro is crafted as a dependable, all-around winter glove that bridges the gap between everyday casual wear and technical outdoor recreation. OutdoorGearLab awarded it top honors as an all-around winter option due to its approachable blend of weatherproofing, balanced insulation, and practical everyday ergonomics. It suits skiers, winter hikers, and commuters looking for a single, reliable glove that can handle varied conditions without breaking the bank. Built with a durable softshell and nylon exterior, the Sureshot Pro incorporates Outdoor Research's proprietary waterproof insert to keep melting snow from reaching your fingers. A balanced layer of synthetic insulation provides sufficient heat retention for typical freezing winter temperatures without inflating the glove into an unwieldy mitten. Leather reinforcements across the palm and fingertips ensure steady friction when grasping ski poles, snow shovels, or steering wheels. The glove's mid-length undercuff design keeps the silhouette tidy, though it requires tucking neatly beneath your jacket sleeves to prevent powder from blowing in during deep snow activities. While it handles standard winter sports and town duties admirably, it lacks the expedition-level warmth required for severe sub-zero cold snaps, and its breathability is moderate during steep, sweat-inducing ascents. **Highlights** - Balanced synthetic insulation provides reliable warmth for everyday winter activities - Waterproof breathable membrane reliably repels slush, snow, and rain - Leather-reinforced palm improves long-term abrasion resistance and grip security - Undercuff design integrates cleanly with a wide variety of jacket sleeves - Touchscreen-friendly design allows basic smartphone use in cold weather **Watch-outs** - Undercuff styling can allow snow intrusion if jacket cuffs are not secured - Breathability falls short during high-output backcountry touring - May leave fingers cold in sustained, single-digit sub-zero temperatures

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Stormtracker Sensor Windbloc

#6 on this list

Stormtracker Sensor Windbloc

Outdoor Research

The Outdoor Research Stormtracker Sensor Windbloc has long been a benchmark among climbers, ski tourers, and mountaineers who require maximum articulation in cold, windy conditions. Earning consistent praise as an all-around technical glove, the Stormtracker prioritizes dexterity above heavy insulation. It is built for active people who need to handle carabiners, adjust ski pole cams, work with ropes, or zip technical layers without pulling off their handwear. Its shell relies on windproof Gore-Tex Infinium Windstopper softshell fabric, which shuts down biting winds while allowing accumulated sweat to evaporate quickly during intense aerobic efforts. The palm is built from durable water-resistant goat leather that provides exceptional tactile sensitivity and grip. A lightweight tricot fleece lining lines the interior, supplying low-bulk insulation that keeps hands functional when moving quickly in freezing mountain air. Because the Stormtracker is an active softshell glove, it does have distinct limits. It lacks heavy thermal fill, so fingers will quickly chill if you stop moving in low temperatures or ride slow chairlifts in mid-winter conditions. Additionally, while the fabric and leather repel light dampness and wind, seams are not sealed against standing water or heavy, wet downpours. It remains an athletic tool rather than a deep-winter shield. **Highlights** - Gore-Tex Infinium Windstopper fabric completely blocks biting mountain gusts - Supple goat leather palm offers exceptional tactile sensitivity and pole grip - Lightweight, breathable build keeps hands dry during high-output ascents - Sensor touchscreen technology on index finger and thumb works reliably - Zippered wrist gusset provides a secure, streamlined fit over the wrist **Watch-outs** - Minimal insulation means cold hands during inactive periods or severe freezes - Water-resistant rather than fully waterproof; vulnerable to soaking wet snow - Snug, athletic fit leaves little room for wearing thicker liner gloves inside

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Sureshot Pro - Men's versus Stormtracker Sensor Windbloc specifications
SpecSureshot Pro - Men'sStormtracker Sensor Windbloc
Glove StyleUnder-cuff insulated five-finger glove—
MembraneProprietary waterproof insert—
Insulation TypeMidweight synthetic fill—
Palm MaterialAbrasion-resistant leather reinforcementWater-resistant goat leather
Cuff DesignLow-profile undercuff with hook-and-loop closureZippered wrist gusset
TouchscreenSensor-compatible fingertip constructionSensor technology on thumb and index
Retail Price—Around $79
Shell Fabric—Nylon softshell with Gore-Tex Infinium
Lining—Lightweight tricot fleece

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Sureshot Pro - Men's

  • Balanced synthetic insulation provides solid warmth without excessive bulk
  • Waterproof membrane effectively repels wet snow, sleet, and slush
  • Leather-reinforced palm delivers reliable grip and resists abrasion
  • Low-profile undercuff fits smoothly underneath jacket sleeves
  • Touchscreen-compatible fingertips allow basic smartphone use in the cold
  • Lacks sufficient insulation for severe, single-digit sub-zero temperatures
  • Undercuff design allows snow entry if jacket sleeves are not secured tightly
  • Breathability is limited during high-output uphill touring

Stormtracker Sensor Windbloc

  • Class-leading articulation for managing hardware, ropes, and bindings.
  • Gore-Tex Infinium shell reliably shuts down harsh alpine winds.
  • Supple goat leather palm offers dependable grip and tactile sensitivity.
  • Low-bulk cuff design slides easily underneath technical jacket sleeves.
  • Minimal thermal insulation causes cold fingers during stationary periods.
  • Lacks sealed seams, making it susceptible to soaking in wet precipitation.
  • Athletic, narrow fit leaves very little interior room for liner gloves.

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.