Skip to content
Wild10

Become a contributor

Join

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Top 10 Wind River Trout Lakes head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Deep Lake

#4 on this list

Deep Lake

Bridger Wilderness, Wyoming

Deep Lake rests at 10,500 feet directly beneath the monolithic west face of Haystack Mountain. It is one of the premier high-elevation cutthroat waters reached from the Big Sandy Trailhead on the southern tip of the range. The lake's deep, cold trench produces surprisingly thick Yellowstone cutthroats and occasional goldens that feed along the talus edges. The hike in covers roughly 12 miles from Big Sandy, passing through meadows before grinding up through Temple and Miller Lake basins. Boulder town is the nearest stop for fuel, while Lander or Pinedale serve as full-service hubs. The basin sits just below the Continental Divide, meaning weather shifts occur with frightening speed. The fishing strategy here centers on working the deep breaklines where vertical granite slabs drop into turquoise water. Wind-blown terrestrial patterns like foam beetles and hoppers work well along the windward shores from late July through August. **Highlights** * Elevation: 10,510 feet * Target species: Yellowstone cutthroat trout, golden trout * Trailhead: Big Sandy (12 miles one-way) * World-class alpine rock-climbing scenery beneath Haystack Mountain * Consistent action on dry-dropper rigs along drop-offs **Watch-outs** * Rough, washboard gravel road driving into Big Sandy Trailhead * Severe rockfall danger near the base of vertical cirque walls * High foot traffic along lower approach trails shared with climbers

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Lonesome Lake

#5 on this list

Lonesome Lake

Popo Agie Wilderness, Wyoming

Lonesome Lake is the geographic centerpiece of the famed Cirque of the Towers, sitting at 10,166 feet. Ringed by vertical spires like Pingora and the Watchtower, the lake supports a robust population of wild cutthroat trout. These fish thrive on the insect life produced around the inlet marsh and the shallow delta formed by snowmelt. Reaching Lonesome Lake requires an 8.5 to 10-mile hike from the Big Sandy Trailhead over Jackass Pass. It is a grueling haul with a heavy pack, particularly the steep scramble over the pass's boulder field. Because this is one of the most visited locations in the Rocky Mountains, human impact rules are stringent: camping is completely prohibited within a quarter-mile of the lakeshore to allow the alpine zone to recover. Fishing here is best treated as a day effort from camps outside the closure zone. Midges and small mayfly spinners yield consistent hookups in the early morning before climbers start shouting from the ridges and the afternoon winds kick up. **Highlights** * Elevation: 10,166 feet * Target species: Cutthroat trout * Shortest alpine hike on this list (approx. 9 miles from Big Sandy) * World-renowned mountain architecture of the Cirque of the Towers * Highly active surface-feeding cutthroats in the inlet channels **Watch-outs** * Strict camping closure within 1/4 mile of the entire lake * Major campsite crowding outside the closure perimeter * Intensive wilderness ranger patrols and zero-tolerance fire bans

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Deep Lake versus Lonesome Lake specifications
SpecDeep LakeLonesome Lake
Elevation10,510 feet (3,203 m)10,166 feet
Managing AgencyBridger-Teton National Forest—
Primary TrailheadBig Sandy TrailheadBig Sandy Opening
One-Way DistanceApproximately 12 miles—
Target SpeciesYellowstone cutthroat trout, golden troutCutthroat trout
Best WindowLate July through early September—
Hike Distance—9 miles one way
Access Difficulty—Strenuous alpine pass crossing
Governing Agency—USFS Popo Agie Wilderness

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Deep Lake

  • Produces exceptionally sturdy, high-elevation Yellowstone cutthroat trout
  • Dramatic amphitheater setting directly underneath Haystack Mountain's cliffs
  • Deep breaklines allow productive shoreline fly fishing without watercraft
  • Established approach trail is straightforward to follow for a remote water
  • Heavy user traffic around trailhead and approach trails due to climbers
  • Complete lack of tree cover leaves camps exposed to violent wind and lightning
  • High-altitude boulder hopping required to reach prime water along the bank

Lonesome Lake

  • High-density population of eager, wild alpine cutthroat trout
  • Unrivaled amphitheater setting flanked by Pingora Peak and vertical spires
  • Reliable insect hatches and surface activity along shallow inlet deltas
  • Relatively short trail approach compared to interior Wind River Range waters
  • Camping strictly banned within a quarter-mile of the entire lakeshore
  • Heavy hiker and climber traffic diminishes genuine wilderness solitude
  • Jackass Pass boulder field is grueling and hazardous with loaded packs

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.