Skip to content
Wild10

Become a contributor

Join

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Top 10 Wind River Trout Lakes head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Lonesome Lake

#5 on this list

Lonesome Lake

Popo Agie Wilderness, Wyoming

Lonesome Lake is the geographic centerpiece of the famed Cirque of the Towers, sitting at 10,166 feet. Ringed by vertical spires like Pingora and the Watchtower, the lake supports a robust population of wild cutthroat trout. These fish thrive on the insect life produced around the inlet marsh and the shallow delta formed by snowmelt. Reaching Lonesome Lake requires an 8.5 to 10-mile hike from the Big Sandy Trailhead over Jackass Pass. It is a grueling haul with a heavy pack, particularly the steep scramble over the pass's boulder field. Because this is one of the most visited locations in the Rocky Mountains, human impact rules are stringent: camping is completely prohibited within a quarter-mile of the lakeshore to allow the alpine zone to recover. Fishing here is best treated as a day effort from camps outside the closure zone. Midges and small mayfly spinners yield consistent hookups in the early morning before climbers start shouting from the ridges and the afternoon winds kick up. **Highlights** * Elevation: 10,166 feet * Target species: Cutthroat trout * Shortest alpine hike on this list (approx. 9 miles from Big Sandy) * World-renowned mountain architecture of the Cirque of the Towers * Highly active surface-feeding cutthroats in the inlet channels **Watch-outs** * Strict camping closure within 1/4 mile of the entire lake * Major campsite crowding outside the closure perimeter * Intensive wilderness ranger patrols and zero-tolerance fire bans

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Washakie Lake

#6 on this list

Washakie Lake

Bridger Wilderness, Wyoming

Resting at 10,360 feet on the northern side of Washakie Pass, Washakie Lake is a sprawling, multi-armed alpine water that feels vast and barren. The lake is fed by high-elevation permanent snowfields, keeping temperatures low enough that cutthroat and golden hybrids remain active in the shallows throughout midsummer. Access is best achieved via the Big Sandy Trailhead or Scab Creek, but either route requires at least 15 to 17 miles of rugged wilderness travel. The lake acts as a transition point between the southern cirques and the central high plateau, seeing far fewer visitors than Lonesome Lake. Lander is the logical logistical base if crossing over from the east via Washakie Pass. The lake's convoluted shoreline provides numerous sheltered coves where cruisers escape main-basin wind. Casting small beadhead nymphs under an attractor dry fly along submerged granite points produces steady action throughout August. **Highlights** * Elevation: 10,360 feet * Target species: Cutthroat trout, golden trout hybrids * Mileage: 16 miles one-way from Big Sandy via Hailey Pass trail * Intricate shoreline with isolated bays and rocky peninsulas * Excellent jumping-off point for exploring higher, unnamed tarns **Watch-outs** * High-elevation pass crossings (Washakie or Hailey) can harbor steep snow fields * Expansive water makes finding fish difficult without binoculars * Gale-force winds funnel directly across the lake from the divide

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Lonesome Lake versus Washakie Lake specifications
SpecLonesome LakeWashakie Lake
Elevation10,166 feet10,360 feet
Target SpeciesCutthroat troutCutthroat trout, golden trout hybrids
Primary TrailheadBig Sandy Opening—
Hike Distance9 miles one way—
Access DifficultyStrenuous alpine pass crossing—
Governing AgencyUSFS Popo Agie Wilderness—
Location—Bridger Wilderness, Wind River Range, Wyoming
Trailhead Access—Big Sandy or Scab Creek
Minimum Distance—15 to 17 miles one-way
Management Agency—USFS - Bridger-Teton National Forest

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Lonesome Lake

  • High-density population of eager, wild alpine cutthroat trout
  • Unrivaled amphitheater setting flanked by Pingora Peak and vertical spires
  • Reliable insect hatches and surface activity along shallow inlet deltas
  • Relatively short trail approach compared to interior Wind River Range waters
  • Camping strictly banned within a quarter-mile of the entire lakeshore
  • Heavy hiker and climber traffic diminishes genuine wilderness solitude
  • Jackass Pass boulder field is grueling and hazardous with loaded packs

Washakie Lake

  • Substantially lighter foot traffic than lakes along the Cirque of the Towers loop
  • Healthy population of willing cutthroat and golden hybrids along drop-offs
  • Extensive shoreline structure with numerous sheltered bays to escape gusts
  • High-elevation basecamp with direct access to higher, seldom-fished alpine tarns
  • Minimum 15-mile trek with substantial elevation gain limits trip feasibility
  • Strong, persistent divide winds can quickly shut down fly presentation
  • Very little tree cover along the shoreline to shelter tents from severe storms

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.