Skip to content

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Camping Mattresses head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Foamy Sleeping Pad

#10 on this list

Foamy Sleeping Pad

Hest

The Hest Foamy Sleeping Pad strips away mechanical valves and air bladders entirely, providing a pure memory foam camp bed praised by Switchback Travel for effortless setup. Unlike self-inflating pads that require burping, pumping, or careful puncture management, the Foamy simply unrolls and is immediately ready to sleep on, making late-night camp arrivals completely stress-free. Independent testers praise the Foamy for its durable dual-layer foam construction, which pairs a plush body-contouring upper layer with a firm, resilient lower base that keeps hips and shoulders elevated off the hard deck. Measuring 78 by 25 by 3.9 inches, it provides four inches of uninterrupted cushioning. The bottom fabric is rugged and water-resistant, allowing it to be used directly on damp grass, frozen ground, or rough wood platforms without fear of failure. The glaring drawback is weight and packed size: at an imposing 11 pounds, the Foamy is strictly a car, truck, or van-bound mattress. Rolling it tight enough to secure the integrated compression clips takes significant upper-body effort. For vehicle campers who prioritize zero setup time and guaranteed puncture-proof reliability, it is a formidable contender. **Highlights** - 100% foam construction means zero risk of punctures or mid-night leaks - Generous 3.9-inch thickness provides outstanding body cushioning - Instant setup with no valves, inflation pumps, or air topping required - Durable, water-resistant base material protects against dirt and moisture - Integrated roll-up straps and carry handle for tailgate transport **Watch-outs** - Extremely heavy at 11 pounds - Does not pack down small, taking up substantial trunk volume - Compressing and buckling the rolled foam requires noticeable physical effort

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
MegaMat

#1 on this list

MegaMat

Exped

The Exped MegaMat remains the undisputed gold standard among self-inflating camp mattresses, sweeping top awards across independent testing outlets for both solo campers and couples. Engineered with open-cell polyurethane foam bonded to a durable stretch-tricot face fabric, it creates an exceptionally level, supportive sleeping surface that eliminates the bouncy, unstable feel typical of conventional air beds. It functions as a true four-season mattress, insulating campers against frozen ground while preventing pressure points at the hips and shoulders. In field assessments by major outlets, the MegaMat consistently scores at the top of the chart for pure sleeping comfort and thermal performance. The vertical sidewalls allow mattresses to be placed flush against each other or paired seamlessly inside a tent without creating a dead zone between sleepers. Deflation and rolling do require deliberate effort and technique due to the dense internal foam, but the oversized valves and dedicated purge systems make the process manageable once mastered. At roughly $450 in double configurations and weighing over five and a half pounds, it represents a serious investment in comfort and cargo space. For regular car campers, overlanders, or anyone using a cot, the build quality and sleep quality justify the price tag and the bulky packed footprint. **Highlights** - Open-cell foam core delivers consistent, firm support without bouncy air displacement - Soft stretch-tricot top fabric reduces rustling noise and feels soft against skin - 3D vertical sidewalls maximize usable sleeping area edge-to-edge - High-volume deflation and micro-adjust valves streamline firmness adjustments - Excellent thermal insulation for cold-weather ground sleeping **Watch-outs** - Expensive relative to traditional car-camping air beds - Large rolled dimensions occupy substantial trunk space - Requires deliberate knee-work and effort to compress and pack away

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Foamy Sleeping Pad versus MegaMat specifications
SpecFoamy Sleeping PadMegaMat
Pad TypeSolid dual-layer open-cell foam—
Dimensions78 x 25 x 3.9 in.—
Weight11 lb. 0 oz.5 lb. 11.7 oz.
Inflation MethodNone (ready instantly upon unrolling)—
Packed StyleRoll-up cylinder with integrated straps—
Approximate Price$279Around $450 in double configurations
Design Style—Self-inflating foam core
Top Material—Stretch-tricot polyester
Internal Core—Open-cell polyurethane foam
Intended Season—True four-season performance

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Foamy Sleeping Pad

  • Pure foam build eliminates the risk of midnight deflation and punctures
  • Instantly ready to sleep on with zero pumping, blowing, or valving required
  • Dual-layer 3.9-inch profile cushions hips and shoulders off hard ground
  • Durable, water-resistant bottom fabric handles direct contact with dirt
  • Massive packed volume takes up substantial vehicle cargo space
  • Heavy 11-pound weight restricts use strictly to vehicle camping
  • Rolling and cinching the dense foam demands noticeable physical effort

MegaMat

  • Supple stretch-tricot fabric eliminates noise and sleeping bag sliding
  • Vertical sidewall geometry maximizes edge-to-edge sleeping area
  • Dense foam core yields true bed-like stability without bouncy air shifts
  • Exceptional thermal protection suited for winter ground camping
  • Deflation and roll-up demand considerable physical effort and technique
  • Packed volume consumes significant trunk space in compact vehicles
  • Steep initial investment compared to traditional camping air beds

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.