Skip to content

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Kayaks head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Pungo 120

#1 on this list

Pungo 120

Wilderness Systems

The Wilderness Systems Pungo 120 is widely regarded across the paddling industry as the benchmark for sit-inside recreational performance. Designed primarily for flatwater lakes, slow-moving rivers, and coastal inlets, this twelve-foot boat blends the primary stability beginners need with the glide and tracking that seasoned paddlers appreciate. Its multichine hull profile lets the boat track true across open stretches of water without demanding constant corrective strokes, making it far more efficient over distance than stubby entry-level models. Much of the Pungo's enduring reputation stems from its cockpit outfitting. The Phase 3 AirStream seat offers extensive adjustability, allowing paddlers to dial in leg support, backrest height, and tilt to stave off fatigue during long sessions. The large cockpit opening facilitates effortless entry and exit, while the removable dashboard console adds functional utility with dry storage pockets and mounting points for accessories. Rotomolded high-density polyethylene construction ensures the hull withstands groundings, rough launches, and heavy sun exposure over years of regular use. The trade-offs here reflect its category. At 12 feet long and roughly 50 pounds, loading the Pungo solo onto a tall vehicle roof rack requires reasonable upper-body strength or lift-assist hardware. It is also not an open-ocean craft; while it handles light chop with ease, the large cockpit opening will take on water in heavy surf or technical rapids without a fitted spray skirt. **Highlights** - Multichine hull engineered for strong tracking and reassuring secondary stability - Phase 3 AirStream seating system with multi-point ergonomic adjustment - Large, accessible cockpit opening for effortless entry and exit - Configurable, removable dashboard console with splash-resistant storage - Sealed stern bulkhead paired with an Orbix hatch for dry gear stowage **Watch-outs** - Relatively heavy to lift and load solo onto high roof racks - Large cockpit aperture can ship water in choppy open-water conditions

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Loon 120

#2 on this list

Loon 120

Old Town

The Old Town Loon 120 rivals the top spot in recreational paddling, offering a traditional, exceptionally stable sit-inside experience. Old Town built the Loon around a sharp keel line and a clean entry bow, giving it surprisingly fast acceleration and crisp forward tracking for a boat in this class. It targets paddlers who want a dependable, do-it-all platform for lakes, ponds, and calm tidal marshes without dealing with the sluggishness common to wide recreation hulls. Construction is based on Old Town's three-layer polyethylene process, which creates a rigid, impact-resistant hull that limits hull flex under power while shrugging off impacts against submerged gravel and dock edges. Comfort is anchored by the Active Comfort System 2.0 (ACS2) seat, which provides intuitive pull-cord adjustments, breathable padding, and solid lumbar support. The boat also features a removable workdeck equipped with dry storage and USB-ready cord routes, giving day-trippers and casual anglers a tidy place to secure gear within reach. The durability of three-layer polyethylene comes at the cost of weight. The Loon 120 is noticeably heavy, making transport from vehicle to water a workout without a dedicated cart. Additionally, its tracking efficiency means turning requires deliberate edging or wide sweep strokes compared to more maneuverable, rockered river craft. **Highlights** - Rigid three-layer polyethylene construction built for maximum impact resistance - Sharp keel design delivering clean tracking and efficient glide - ACS2 seating system featuring straightforward cord-operated adjustability - Removable workdeck with integrated hatch and gear tracks - Stern Click Seal hatch providing watertight storage behind a sealed bulkhead **Watch-outs** - Substantial overall weight makes solo transport and cartopping cumbersome - Stiff tracking reduces responsiveness in tight, winding river channels

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Pungo 120 versus Loon 120 specifications
SpecPungo 120Loon 120
Length12 ft 2 in (371 cm)12 feet
Boat Weight49 lbs (22 kg)—
Weight Capacity325 lbs (147 kg)—
Cockpit Size57 in x 22 in (145 cm x 56 cm)—
Hull MaterialRotomolded High-Density Polyethylene—
Primary WaterwayLakes, slow rivers, and sheltered coastal bays—
Kayak Style—Sit-inside recreational
Hull Construction—Three-layer polyethylene
Seating System—Active Comfort System 2.0 (ACS2)
Bulkhead Storage—Stern Click Seal hatch
Deck Outfitting—Removable utility workdeck

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Pungo 120

  • Efficient tracking and forward glide compared to standard recreational boats
  • Phase 3 AirStream seat offers exceptional ergonomic adjustment points
  • Spacious cockpit opening allows simple entries and relaxed seating posture
  • Durable rotomolded polyethylene hull withstands heavy impacts and dragging
  • At roughly 49 pounds, solo rooftop loading requires deliberate effort
  • Oversized cockpit rim permits water ingress in heavy wind chop or surf
  • Single stern bulkhead lacks backup bow flotation for open-water rescues

Loon 120

  • Rigid three-layer polyethylene hull withstands heavy impacts and resists flexing
  • Sharp keel and bow entry deliver excellent straight-line tracking and glide
  • ACS2 seating system provides comprehensive, cord-adjustable ergonomic support
  • Removable cockpit workdeck offers handy dry storage and accessory mounting
  • Substantial overall weight makes solo transport and cartopping demanding
  • Strong forward tracking limits quick turning in narrow, winding streams

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.