Skip to content

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Custom Recurves head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
PCH X / PCH V

#8 on this list

PCH X / PCH V

Black Widow Bows

The Black Widow Bows PCH X / PCH V are for the traditional bowhunter who wants the renowned Black Widow quality and performance in a more compact package. These 58-60 inch custom takedowns, often specified around 47-48 pounds draw weight, are the hunting-focused siblings to their longer counterparts. They offer the same meticulous build-to-order process, ensuring a perfectly tailored bow, but with an emphasis on agility and ease of handling in the field. Construction parallels other Black Widow models, featuring dense phenolic risers that provide stability and deaden hand shock, often accented with exotic woods. The PCH X and PCH V refer to different riser designs, allowing for varied grip ergonomics and balance points. Limbs are crafted for a smooth draw up to moderate draw lengths and efficient energy transfer for good arrow speed. The compact length makes them ideal for treestands, ground blinds, or still-hunting through thick brush. Trade-offs remain the premium price and the customary wait for a custom build, but the established resale market for Black Widows helps mitigate the investment. **Highlights** * Black Widow's renowned quality in a compact hunting platform * 58-60 inch lengths ideal for tight hunting spots * Dense phenolic risers for stability and hand shock dampening * Customizable draw weight, grip, and aesthetic options * Excellent resale value and long-term durability **Watch-outs** * Premium price point * Long lead times for custom orders * Shorter length might stack slightly for very long draw lengths

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Silvertip Takedown

#9 on this list

Silvertip Takedown

Schafer Bows

The Schafer Bows Silvertip Takedown is an heirloom choice, designed for the bowhunter who values timeless beauty, exceptional craftsmanship, and proven hunting performance that can be passed down through generations. This custom takedown recurve is lauded for its exquisite finish, smooth draw, and excellent shootability, earning it a loyal following among traditional bowhunters who appreciate classic design and meticulous attention to detail. Construction is characterized by stunning wood combinations, often featuring striking riser woods paired with finely crafted limbs. The fit and finish are exceptional, with a level of refinement that stands out even among other high-end custom bows. Each Silvertip is built to order, allowing the customer to specify draw weight, draw length, and aesthetic preferences, ensuring a truly personalized bow. The takedown design makes it practical for transport, while the precision of the limb pockets maintains superb alignment. The main trade-offs are the significant investment and the extended lead times, but the Silvertip's reputation for longevity and its status as a highly desirable piece of archery history make it a worthwhile commitment. **Highlights** * Heirloom quality and exquisite finish * Stunning wood combinations and craftsmanship * Smooth drawing and highly shootable * Proven performance for hunting applications * Precise takedown system for consistent alignment **Watch-outs** * High-end price point * Extended lead times for custom orders * May require more careful handling due to fine finish

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

PCH X / PCH V versus Silvertip Takedown specifications
SpecPCH X / PCH VSilvertip Takedown
Bow TypeCustom Takedown Recurve—
Lengths58-60 inches—
Riser MaterialPhenolic, exotic woods—
Draw WeightCustom to order—
Lead TimeMonths to ~1 year (confirm directly)—
MakerBlack Widow Bows—
Type—Takedown Recurve
Construction—Custom Wood Riser & Laminated Limbs
Personalization—Draw weight, length, grip, wood choice
Resale Value—High
Category—Heirloom Quality Bow

What our reviewers liked and didn't

PCH X / PCH V

  • Exceptional maneuverability in tight hunting environments
  • Legendary Black Widow build quality and reliability
  • Custom draw weight and grip tailored to the archer
  • Excellent hand shock dampening from phenolic riser
  • Outstanding resale value and long-term durability
  • Premium price point, significant investment
  • Extended lead times for custom orders
  • Shorter length can lead to more aggressive string angle for very long draws

Silvertip Takedown

  • Heirloom quality and exceptional craftsmanship
  • Superb shooting characteristics: smooth draw, stable, quiet
  • Highly customizable to individual archer's specs
  • Excellent resale value and desirability
  • Classic aesthetics and stunning wood combinations
  • Significant lead times for custom orders
  • High investment, not for budget-conscious buyers
  • Fine finish requires careful handling in the field

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.