Skip to content

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Takedown Recurves head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
Black Wolf ILF Recurve

#2 on this list

Black Wolf ILF Recurve

Win&Win (WNS)

The Win&Win (WNS) Black Wolf is a formidable ILF hunting recurve born from a company with deep roots in Olympic-level target archery. It's for the hunter who appreciates the advanced material science and engineering typically found in competition bows, but wants it adapted for the robust demands of the field. This bow is an excellent choice for those who want a smooth, efficient shot experience and the vast limb compatibility that the ILF standard provides. Performance-wise, the Black Wolf is exceptionally smooth to draw, even at higher poundages, and exhibits very little hand shock. This is often attributed to the carbon construction of the riser, which can dampen vibration better than aluminum. Accuracy is high, as expected from a WNS product, allowing for tight groups with good form. It feels balanced in hand and points naturally. The takedown mechanism is straightforward ILF, allowing for quick assembly and disassembly, making it ideal for travel. You can literally swap limbs from a light practice set to heavy hunting limbs in minutes, a huge advantage for progression or varied hunting needs. Its construction utilizes carbon in the riser, which contributes to its light weight and vibration dampening properties. This is a step up from many aluminum risers in terms of feel. Being an ILF system, it means you can pair it with any ILF-compatible limbs, from budget-friendly options to high-performance carbon-foam cores. While it might not have the same rugged, overbuilt aesthetic of some traditional hunting bows, its performance and adaptability make it a top contender for the discerning hunter. It's widely stocked by major archery dealers, making parts and accessories readily available.

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
PSA Custom Recurve

#3 on this list

PSA Custom Recurve

Black Widow Bows

The Black Widow PSA Custom Recurve is an American icon, a three-piece bolt-down takedown with a legacy spanning over 65 years. This bow is for the serious, traditional bowhunter who prioritizes raw performance, rock-solid consistency, and heirloom quality. It's not about trends or ultra-modern features; it's about a proven design that simply works, year after year, hunt after hunt. Many Black Widow owners are fiercely loyal, and for good reason. In the field, the PSA is a "nail-driver." Its design provides exceptional stability, often feeling heavier in the hand than its actual weight, which aids in a steady aim. The draw is typically smooth, and while it might not be the absolute fastest bow on the market, its ability to consistently put arrows where you're looking is its greatest strength. The bolt-down limb attachment system, while proprietary, is incredibly secure. Once assembled, it feels like a one-piece bow, eliminating any concerns about limb movement or noise. The finish and craftsmanship are top-tier, showcasing fine hardwoods and meticulous assembly. It's a bow that can be passed down through generations. Construction involves carefully selected hardwoods for the riser and laminated limbs, all built to rigorous standards. The proprietary limb system means you're tied into Black Widow's limbs, but their quality is excellent, and they offer a range of draw weights. The takedown is straightforward, requiring an Allen wrench to remove the limb bolts. While it's not as quick as a tool-free system, it's a secure connection that's proven its reliability in countless hunting seasons. This bow represents a significant investment, but for many, its enduring performance and classic appeal are worth every penny.

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

Black Wolf ILF Recurve versus PSA Custom Recurve specifications
SpecBlack Wolf ILF RecurvePSA Custom Recurve
SystemILF Takedown—
Riser MaterialCarbonExotic Hardwoods
Hand ShockVery Low—
Target UserIntermediate to Advanced Hunters—
VersatilityHigh (limb swaps)—
ManufacturerWin&Win (WNS)—
Bow Type—Takedown Recurve
Limb Attachment—Proprietary Bolt-Down
Limb Construction—Laminated
Travel—Three-piece breakdown
Origin—USA

What our reviewers liked and didn't

Black Wolf ILF Recurve

  • Carbon riser offers superior vibration dampening and light weight
  • Exceptionally smooth draw and minimal hand shock
  • ILF system allows for vast limb compatibility and easy poundage progression
  • Breaks down quickly for compact travel and backpack hunts
  • High inherent accuracy and stable aiming characteristics
  • Aesthetics might be too modern for traditionalists
  • Not as readily available as some mainstream aluminum risers
  • Requires separate purchase of limbs, string, and accessories

PSA Custom Recurve

  • Heirloom quality and proven durability
  • Exceptional stability and shot consistency
  • Smooth draw and quiet performance
  • Solid, integrated feel once assembled
  • American-made craftsmanship
  • Significant financial investment
  • Proprietary limbs limit choices
  • Bolt-down system not as quick as tool-free
  • Not the fastest recurve on the market

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.