Skip to content

Top 10 · Compare

Compare Turkey Arrow Builds head to head

Pick any two picks from this list and see specs, current price, pros, cons and reader ratings side by side.

Share
Follow
Back to the full Top 10
5mm Axis Match Grade Shaft

#5 on this list

5mm Axis Match Grade Shaft

Easton

The Easton 5mm Axis Match Grade Shaft is a serious contender for any dedicated turkey arrow build, particularly when you're shooting oversized broadheads. What sets it apart is its small diameter coupled with a heavier carbon construction. This combination does a few critical things: the small diameter reduces wind drift and increases penetration potential (though with turkey heads, we're often trying to limit pass-throughs, the stability is still key). The heavier weight helps boost overall arrow weight, which is beneficial for kinetic energy, especially with broadheads that demand it. Crucially, the weight and inherent stiffness of the Axis Match Grade allow you to achieve a high Front-of-Center (FOC) balance without resorting to excessively heavy inserts or broadheads. A higher FOC is vital for stabilizing large, wind-catching turkey broadheads, making your arrow fly truer and more consistently. This shaft provides a solid, stable foundation for those big heads, minimizing oscillation and ensuring a straighter flight path to the target. It’s a premium shaft for a premium build, designed for hunters who demand precision and reliability. **Highlights** * Small diameter reduces wind drift and enhances stability * Heavier carbon construction increases overall arrow weight * Facilitates higher FOC for superior broadhead stabilization * Excellent consistency and straightness tolerances * Durable for repeated use and impacts **Watch-outs** * Higher price point than many standard carbon shafts * Small diameter requires specific components (nocks, inserts) * Can be more difficult to pull from dense targets due to friction * Less forgiving of poor tuning or shooting form compared to larger diameters

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched
Hunter XT Shaft

#6 on this list

Hunter XT Shaft

Gold Tip

The Gold Tip Hunter XT Shaft is a workhorse, a reliable and widely available option for hunters looking to build a dedicated turkey arrow without breaking the bank. It's known for its durability, consistent spine, and forgiveness, making it a solid choice for a specialized build. While it's not a micro-diameter shaft, its standard diameter provides good strength and is easier to work with for most bowhunters, especially when cutting, fletching, and installing inserts. This is a shaft that can take a beating, which is important when hunting turkeys where arrows might end up in the dirt or against obstacles. For turkey hunting, the Hunter XT's consistent spine and moderate weight allow for good arrow flight, especially when paired with reasonable broadheads. It's not the absolute lightest or heaviest, but it provides a good foundation for building a balanced arrow with sufficient FOC, particularly if you use heavier inserts or broadheads. Its wide availability means replacement shafts or components are easy to find. It’s a practical, no-nonsense choice that delivers reliable performance without the premium cost associated with some specialty shafts, making it an excellent base for an affordable yet effective turkey arrow setup. **Highlights** * Excellent durability and reliability * Consistent spine for predictable flight * Widely available and easy to source components * Good value for a dedicated turkey arrow build * Forgiving for various tuning levels **Watch-outs** * Standard diameter; not as wind-resistant as micro-diameter shafts * Moderate weight, might require heavier inserts for optimal FOC with very light heads * Finish can show wear and tear over time * Not a 'speed' shaft if that's a primary concern

Price
Check current price
Reader rating
No reader votes yet
How we assessed it
Specification researched

Specs side by side

5mm Axis Match Grade Shaft versus Hunter XT Shaft specifications
Spec5mm Axis Match Grade ShaftHunter XT Shaft
Shaft Diameter5mm (0.197 inches)—
MaterialHigh-Strength Carbon—
Straightness+/- .001 inches—
Insert SystemDeep Six (HIT)—
Optimal UseHeavy/High-FOC Broadhead Setups—
GPI Range8.8 - 11.5 (depending on spine)—
Shaft Material—Carbon
Diameter—Standard
Straightness Tolerance—.003"
Availability—Widespread
Manufacturer—Gold Tip

What our reviewers liked and didn't

5mm Axis Match Grade Shaft

  • Exceptional straightness and weight consistency
  • Small diameter reduces wind drift significantly
  • Heavy carbon design aids in high FOC for broadhead stability
  • Highly durable and impact resistant
  • Excellent energy transfer for devastating turkey hits
  • Higher price point than many standard shafts
  • Requires specific Deep Six compatible components
  • Can be harder to pull from dense targets due to friction

Hunter XT Shaft

  • Exceptional durability and resistance to impact
  • Consistent spine and weight for predictable flight
  • Widely available and easy to source replacements/components
  • Forgiving to tune, works well with various setups
  • Excellent value for a dedicated hunting shaft
  • Standard diameter is not as wind-resistant as micro shafts
  • Moderate weight; not a speed-focused shaft
  • Finish can show cosmetic wear quickly

Prices change constantly — the figure shown is the last verified catalog price, and the buy buttons always go to the current listing.